Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLIX - At the Source of Darkness

[Brinniel]

Greenie as a cobbler...well it's a bit of a surprise, but I'm quite relieved...especially that it was the wolves who killed her, which therefore has kept our numbers up. I was worried we would start out toDay with half of us being evil, but luckily that's not the case...but I'm still definitely worried that we haven't yet lynched a wolf, and it's really important that we get this right toDay.

Originally Posted by Durelin

Basically the only way I can try and convince of my innocence that I've thought of is this: if I was actually a wolf, why would I have bothered going after Nogrod so much, especially once it started drawing a great deal of attention to me? But if I was actually a cobbler (I'm going to sound like phantom here), there's a good possibility the cobbler assassin chose me last night or even earlier, if they chose someone that people have been mentioned 'looks like a cobbler'. And I'm not dead. Rather wish the wolves had been nice and taken me out last night, but it's better that they killed another one of their cobblers.

Yeah, I was thinking something similar to that. I seriously half expected to come here toDay and find you had been killed by the assassin...but that's not the case. But I still won't eliminate the possibility that you could be a cobbler...after all, Formy wasn't killed right away. As for being a wolf...I'm pretty torn. It does seem rather bold for a wolf to so strongly attack an ordo. Usually wolves aren't so clear in their suspicions...but not always, as I can recall it's happened before. And of course, it would be easy for a wolf to use the "I wouldn't do that" excuse and play the "sorry I'm such a misguided ordo" card. But is that something Durelin would do? I don't know.

Conclusion: While we should definitely not spend our entire Day focusing on Durelin, we shouldn't eliminate her from being a possible wolf either.

Originally Posted by phantom

Shasta has made 42 posts. More than every one of you.

During those 42 posts he has not given ONE single opinion about ANY of you.

That has got to be the most suspicious thing I've ever seen. How can you have the second most posts of any living player and totally avoid giving opinions?

I've sort of accepted that it's just his style...though a more recent style. Ever since the DW game, Shasta has made hordes of short, chatty posts and in the previous two games he was not a wolf. Of course, that doesn't mean he can't be a wolf this time around...but I wouldn't base suspicions simply on the way he's posting. However, I do agree that I would like to see Shasta share some more opinions about other players.