Why Can't Movies Be Like Books? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

"If I hear not allowed much oftener I'm going to get angry."
Sam Gamgee

Visit The *EVEN NEWER* Barrow-Downs Photo Page

		The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum > Middle-Earth Discussions > The Movies
Why Can't Movies Be Like Books?

Meriadoc1961 Why Can't Movies Be Like... 10-20-2007, 09:51 AM

Folwren I have seen one movie that... 10-20-2007, 10:47 AM

Meriadoc1961 "I think it is possible to... 10-20-2007, 11:07 AM

Sauron the White In the imaginary kingdom of... 10-20-2007, 11:36 AM

Annatar Just as a note, that "orc... 10-20-2007, 11:36 AM

Finduilas [QUOTE=Annatar;534340] ... 10-20-2007, 11:46 AM

Annatar Elbereth takes little or no... 10-20-2007, 12:11 PM

Sauron the White Imrahil would have worked... 10-20-2007, 12:22 PM

Sir Kohran Actually I believe Imrahil... 10-20-2007, 12:25 PM

Sauron the White Meriadoc... since it was... 10-20-2007, 12:53 PM

Meriadoc1961 Annatar wrote: "Not to be... 10-20-2007, 02:12 PM

Folwren Meriadoc - I don't think that... 10-20-2007, 07:41 PM

Sauron the White There certainly are portions... 10-20-2007, 08:23 PM

davem How was that a 'vast... 10-21-2007, 01:37 AM

Annatar The changing of Boromir's... 10-21-2007, 03:27 AM

davem In what sense 'a good thing?'... 10-21-2007, 04:55 AM

Sir Kohran I think it's an improvement.... 10-21-2007, 06:08 AM

Raynor But he plays a very important... 10-21-2007, 06:45 AM

davem Again, that's a matter of... 10-21-2007, 09:18 AM

Finduilas The counsil could have been... 10-21-2007, 09:33 AM

Folwren Heh...Finduilas and davem are... 10-21-2007, 09:46 AM

Sauron the White from davem Correct me... 10-21-2007, 10:20 AM

davem Yes - & your point is? That... 10-21-2007, 10:39 AM

Sauron the White As I wrote in my previous... 10-21-2007, 11:01 AM

Imladris It's more of a general rule... 10-21-2007, 11:58 AM

davem Ok, so your position is that... 10-21-2007, 12:49 PM

Sauron the White from davem NO. My... 10-21-2007, 01:16 PM

davem No, Jackson completely... 10-21-2007, 01:39 PM

Sauron the White Your opinion is worthwhile... 10-21-2007, 02:26 PM

Folwren My dear fellow...your are... 10-21-2007, 03:01 PM

Sauron the White from Folwren You are... 10-21-2007, 03:10 PM

davem Most people on this site have... 10-21-2007, 04:04 PM

Sauron the White No assault on you or anyone... 10-21-2007, 04:25 PM

William Cloud Hicklin I take it you've never seen... 10-21-2007, 09:41 PM

Annatar That quote refers to the... 10-22-2007, 09:13 AM

Sir Kohran Assuming I've got the one... 10-22-2007, 11:35 AM

davem Honestly, I think it depends... 10-22-2007, 12:11 PM

Sir Kohran Let's face it - that's how... 10-22-2007, 02:00 PM

davem All I wanted was to be... 10-22-2007, 02:30 PM

Sir Kohran Tha's the difficulty. Heck, I... 10-22-2007, 03:01 PM

Sauron the White Like many things of this... 10-22-2007, 03:18 PM

davem My problem with the movies is... 10-22-2007, 04:01 PM

Sauron the White from davem That... 10-22-2007, 05:09 PM

Sir Kohran Maybe that's the case. I saw... 10-22-2007, 05:18 PM

Sauron the White For those who criticize the... 10-23-2007, 06:54 AM

davem The difference, as I've... 10-23-2007, 07:23 AM

Sauron the White Davem ... I do appreciate... 10-23-2007, 07:59 AM

William Cloud Hicklin No, actually; not of his own... 10-23-2007, 09:06 AM

Sauron the White WCH - and if PJ wanted that... 10-23-2007, 09:16 AM

William Cloud Hicklin Stuff and nonsense. The... 10-23-2007, 09:14 AM

Sir Kohran I had a big post that covered... 10-23-2007, 09:35 AM

William Cloud Hicklin I actually have little... 10-23-2007, 09:42 AM

davem Images are still more... 10-23-2007, 10:32 AM

Annatar The books contain violence.... 10-23-2007, 11:08 AM

Folwren I wonder if Tolkien would... 10-23-2007, 11:33 AM

Sir Kohran This sounds overly-sensitive.... 10-23-2007, 11:42 AM

Sauron the White Folwren asks an interesting... 10-23-2007, 11:51 AM

Folwren What, the music? :p In... 10-23-2007, 06:41 PM

Sauron the White Folwren... yes you are right.... 10-23-2007, 06:53 PM

William Cloud Hicklin You really think that the... 10-23-2007, 08:47 PM

Sauron the White Could you please provide some... 10-23-2007, 09:16 PM

Folwren I don't know. This is a... 10-24-2007, 08:07 AM

Meriadoc1961 Folwren wrote: "In all... 10-24-2007, 10:50 AM

davem Yes, he depicted in graphic... 10-24-2007, 01:45 AM

Essex very interesting debate. Just... 10-24-2007, 03:34 AM

davem When I was 17 I would have... 10-23-2007, 11:57 AM

William Cloud Hicklin Not Victorian; Mediaeval. ... 10-23-2007, 02:53 PM

Sauron the White That is certainly one very... 10-23-2007, 04:02 PM

Sir Kohran davem? Are you going to... 10-23-2007, 04:32 PM

William Cloud Hicklin To chime in in support of... 10-24-2007, 12:47 PM

Sauron the White WCW - I dearly love LAWRENCE... 10-24-2007, 01:00 PM

William Cloud Hicklin What does this have to do... 10-24-2007, 01:29 PM

Sauron the White WCH- thank you for that... 10-24-2007, 01:37 PM

William Cloud Hicklin Well, that could be said of... 10-24-2007, 01:51 PM

Sauron the White WCH - I think you greatly... 10-24-2007, 02:13 PM

davem Yes, but. That being the case... 10-24-2007, 02:57 PM

Sauron the White from davem Sounds like... 10-24-2007, 03:22 PM

davem One can criticise the quality... 10-24-2007, 03:32 PM

Sauron the White Good point. I believe the... 10-24-2007, 03:35 PM

davem I've yet to come across a... 10-24-2007, 03:44 PM

Sauron the White Allow me to add school... 10-24-2007, 05:25 PM

William Cloud Hicklin In fact he was both- Oxford... 10-24-2007, 08:03 PM

Kath In need of something to... 10-25-2007, 10:45 AM

Folwren Hear, Hear! (Really...I... 10-25-2007, 10:59 AM

Sauron the White Folwren may have nothing else... 10-25-2007, 01:04 PM

davem But the Ring is not 'the be... 10-25-2007, 01:49 PM

Folwren You seem to have nothing... 10-25-2007, 01:55 PM

Sauron the White Folwren. I am in total... 10-25-2007, 02:16 PM

William Cloud Hicklin Oh, no. No no no no no. This... 10-25-2007, 04:17 PM

Sauron the White Forget Shippey. I will read... 10-25-2007, 04:41 PM

davem The 'ring a dong dillo'/ 'fa... 10-26-2007, 02:41 AM

William Cloud Hicklin Then you're being wilfully... 10-26-2007, 08:31 AM

davem StW Have to agree with Mr... 10-26-2007, 09:09 AM

Sauron the White Did Faramir physically have... 10-26-2007, 09:45 AM

davem Sam had it on him & wasn't... 10-26-2007, 09:52 AM

Annatar The movies are not the books.... 10-26-2007, 10:09 AM

davem This is the kind of... 10-26-2007, 10:11 AM

Bêthberry Myself, on the other hand,... 10-26-2007, 10:30 AM

William Cloud Hicklin To which rather arrogant... 10-26-2007, 10:22 AM

William Cloud Hicklin Annatar: But the movies... 10-26-2007, 10:34 AM

William Cloud Hicklin What's yet more frighteneing... 10-26-2007, 10:52 AM

Sauron the White Is it fair to say that the... 10-26-2007, 11:03 AM

William Cloud Hicklin What the text itself says is... 10-26-2007, 11:26 AM

Sauron the White Bethberry... here are the... 10-26-2007, 11:29 AM

Bêthberry My good fellow Sauron the... 10-27-2007, 07:39 AM

Sauron the White If you wanted to see a... 10-27-2007, 07:45 AM

Bêthberry Sauron the White, it is an... 10-27-2007, 10:19 AM

William Cloud Hicklin Just informationally, folks:... 10-27-2007, 01:54 PM

davem The Ring corrupts if you take... 10-26-2007, 12:08 PM

Sauron the White Davem, thank you for your... 10-26-2007, 12:29 PM

davem Sam (in the book) rejected... 10-26-2007, 01:05 PM

Sauron the White Davem ... thank you for that... 10-26-2007, 01:40 PM

William Cloud Hicklin Yes, you're on the right... 10-26-2007, 03:06 PM

Sauron the White It sounds like you have... 10-26-2007, 03:48 PM

William Cloud Hicklin Yep- even Frodo, even Sam,... 10-26-2007, 03:59 PM

Folwren Look...STW...Bombadil was not... 10-26-2007, 04:00 PM

Essex And there's the rub. One of... 10-29-2007, 07:41 AM

davem Well, you have an increase in... 10-26-2007, 04:30 PM

Sauron the White Folwren ..... I do enjoy... 10-26-2007, 05:02 PM

More replies below current depth...

davem Faramir does not need to know... 10-27-2007, 12:05 AM

William Cloud Hicklin One is tempted to respond,... 10-22-2007, 01:04 PM

davem CoH. I bought The Sil in '77... 10-22-2007, 03:11 AM

Sauron the White Davem, I find no fault with... 10-22-2007, 08:54 AM

davem Possibly Arwen has been drawn... 10-21-2007, 10:15 AM

Prev

Previous Post

Next Post

Next

Old

10-26-2007, 12:08 PM

#24

davem

Illustrious Ulair

Join Date: Aug 2002

Location: In the home of lost causes, and forsaken beliefs, and unpopular names,and impossible loyalties

Posts: 4,240

davem is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.

davem is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sauron the White

View Post

Is it fair to say that the Ring corrupts? Is that not the basis for the rejection of it by Gandalf and Galadriel?

The Ring corrupts if you take it & claim it as your own. It doesn't corrupt otherwise. Every individual has the absolute freedom to reject the Ring.

Quote:

davem ... I ask you about Faramir and you respond telling me that Sam was not corrupted and he possessed the ring. thank you. How long of a period of time would you estimate that Sam had the Ring in his possession?

Longer than Faramir. In fact, longer than anyone but Sauron, Isildur, Smeagol, Bilbo & Frodo. If the Ring is instantly corrupting, whether the bearer accepts it or not, Sam should have been corrupted by it.

Quote:

Is that wrong? Which authors or Tolkien scholars should I defer to over what the text itself says?

Well, as I've already stated twice, I've used the text to confirm my argument, rather than Shippey.

__________________
“Everything was an object. If you killed a dwarf you could use it as a weapon – it was no different to other large heavy objects."

davem is offline

« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is Off Forum Rules

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:00 PM.