Orcs creation theory - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Flame of Anor · 07-10-2009, 12:14 PM

now we all know Morgoth cannot made beings himself. Also he has never, too his utmost hatred, been able to wield the flame imperishable, so creating a people all his own is impossible.

Because Eru has to set the Flame in each being, and Mogoth could have corrupted the first Elf or Man, but the next generation the mutant offspring would still need a new Fëa (spirit) and with out Eru's consent the offspring would only be an empty husk with no soul.

But if, in the music of Ainur Morgoth sang of his vision of a people he could command that would bend to his will, then Eru would create them and set them on Arda, and would continue to gift these bodies (orcs) with Fëar. Just as the Ent, Eagles, and a little differnt from the dwarves

07-10-2009, 12:14 PM	#7
Flame of Anor Newly Deceased Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 10	now we all know Morgoth cannot made beings himself. Also he has never, too his utmost hatred, been able to wield the flame imperishable, so creating a people all his own is impossible. Because Eru has to set the Flame in each being, and Mogoth could have corrupted the first Elf or Man, but the next generation the mutant offspring would still need a new Fëa (spirit) and with out Eru's consent the offspring would only be an empty husk with no soul. But if, in the music of Ainur Morgoth sang of his vision of a people he could command that would bend to his will, then Eru would create them and set them on Arda, and would continue to gift these bodies (orcs) with Fëar. Just as the Ent, Eagles, and a little differnt from the dwarves