Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXVI - Úcenite Valto - Planning and Discussion Thread

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Mith

It did add ot the puzzlement though since I tried to divine any significance in my fellow players comments on this thread ..... on the wolf may know more of what is up theory

But then the WW would be concious of this and thus would certainly not do or say anything that would lead one to believe that they knew "what is up". Quite the opposite- anything a WW would say would point, if anywhere, towards ignorance.

Originally Posted by SPM

I would certainly have considered whether a phantom Wolf would be so bold as to ask his fellow villagers effectively to commit suicide, and would almost certainly have concluded that it was a distinct possibility.

Yes, you're entirely right. If I was a WW I would have LOVED to get the villagers to kill themselves like that. That's why I didn't put forth the edit plan on the final day. I figured your mind would lead you to phantom=WW. But of course I wasn't a WW and yet still wanted to do a plan that a WW would try to do. That only goes to highlight what lmp said during the game-

I guess I'm just not used to innocents, IF he's innocent, being more devious than (or as least as devious as) the werewolves.