Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Okay, granted that, what happens? You get killed and the village is on it's own. The odds would be reasonable for the village, I admit. But to say there are no chances for victory for a lonely wolf there is misrepresenting the situation.

I agree with this. The last WW might be hard to catch. Especially if he has special powers of some kind.

Powers like... oh, I dunno... that when he is dreamed of he appears to be an Ordo.

Not that *cough* there is any such Wolf like that.

[Nogrod]

I just picked a few of Boro's statements from the last five pages to show you something. Like I said he needs trust and obedience - and he doesn't like his rivals to disturb his efforts on the former so he'd need to nullify those in some way so that people would not think about them seriously. Let him speak for himself then... with a few short comments (leaving the last one out as I have already discussed it).

morm's got the class to admit he's been caught in a trap...Nog will get there once his pride has fallen...ie once he's lynched. My advice, pay no attention to either of them, just enjoy their company while they are still with us.

Right, pay no attention to the truth as it would be bad.

Instead of doing something constructive to perhaps make himself sound more believable, Nogrod just chooses to be against everything. You know Nogrod, you can't just be against something, you also have to be for something.

Yes, you have the "something" as you are the one pulling the bluff. I don't know how things are but I'm trying my best to figure it out.

I would feel good about doing my part, whatever happens afterwards, well my best goes out to both. But you innocents better not screw it up.

Interesting that you say "whatever happens afterwards". Why so reserved if you were indeed the seer with three wolves bagged? And "you innocents better not screw it up"!? You? So you're not one of them?

I'm stubborn, but I do admit defeat when beaten, and stare back at death.
Maybe I can play one last mind-trick, and tell the last wolf I'll be gone for the next 48 hours so there would be no point in killing me.

Haha, calling for me to shut up appealing to my honour (that's a bit lousy indeed) while already making preparations for you being alive toMorrow! You can now say: "well, I said I will be away and maybe the wolf took it for real... so I'm still alive and an innocent died... no can do"?

No more debates, that's it, final it's been set in stone...or well actually just written in invisble ink.

"Stay the course" village, you have been given orders. It's all set in stone that I'm your seer... Why do you have to underline that all the time? Are you not confident your bluff works?

Good night and no point in wishing good luck, but thank you all for being so cooperative. I wish government could run like that everyday, eh?

"Everything's fine, just trust me"?


Would you buy a used car from this man?

Just compare tp and Boro toDay. Who is relaxed and playful as always - and who is uptight, commanding, nervous, scornful (and needs to make separate small talk all the time to apperar relaxed - I mean see the different tones in his posts!)

And anyway, I'm not going gentle into that good Night if I have a chance to expose Boro's webs before it.

That I'd call dignity. (Or just decent rivalry as in these kinds of games one really doesn't want the other side to win)

[the phantom]

You know, Nog, I'll make a promise to you about Boro.

If he's still alive tomorrow, then I'll believe everything you say and will suggest to the village that he be lynched. I can't speak for anyone else and thus I cannot guarantee it will be done, but I'll sure try.

[A Little Green]

Originally Posted by Nog

the rival Wolfgang

Aww. Just imagining a furry Mozart crawling in the night...

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Aww. Just imagining a furry Mozart crawling in the night...

That's exactly what I had in mind...

Originally Posted by tp

You know, Nog, I'll make a promise to you about Boro.

If he's still alive tomorrow, then I'll believe everything you say and will suggest to the village that he be lynched. I can't speak for anyone else and thus I cannot guarantee it will be done, but I'll sure try.

Belived by who?

This might be even more twisted game I have thought of it thus far.

But I can see your intention tp. You're trying to pre-empt Boro's attack on you the next Night now aren't you? Quite a decent plan I must agree. And sorry to spoil it, but as one that is going to die I'm not feeling too bad about it.

Bah. As soon as it started to look a bit cleaner and more straightforwards then you come with this idle bluff...

I mean on the other hand maybe your story about the cobbler-seer and all the ramifications of it is true then? And it would be not a surprise Fea would pick you two to be involved in there. And thence you're trying to buy Boro some legitimate time (something you could argue for as I spoiled Boro's "I might be off the next 48 hours" thing) as he's your helper in the last account - so even if it looks like he's the master around here then as a cobbler-seer, or whatever he is, he still is indeed your subordinate?

Or do you just trust him? Well I understand you'd not take my advice on this but ask Boro how trusting others can turn out. He has exprerience of it indeed... (sorry Boro, I just had to make that reference as I see it's possible you're trying to use the same trick)

It will be interesting to see how this turns out.

[Brinniel]

I'm currently working on finding all the quotes by our wolves which mention unknowns, and also finding quotes by the unknowns mentioning wolves. But with nearly 1500 posts on this thread, it's quite the monstrous task and I can already see I won't be finishing by the end of toDay since I'm planning to try to go see Spamalot tonight while it's in town. So all those quotes and an analysis will have to wait until toMorrow..

Anyways, I can't really say my thoughts have changed much since my last analysis post. There hasn't been much posting toDay, and many of the posts there have been are just chatter. I suppose toMorrow it'll be much easier to talk when these naughty boys aren't here to distract us..

So unless I can't get a ticket for the show, I probably won't be back again toDay.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Brinniel

There hasn't been much posting toDay, and many of the posts there have been are just chatter. I suppose toMorrow it'll be much easier to talk when these naughty boys aren't here to distract us...

Sadly one of those naughty boys have been one of the few to actually try to boost a discussion.

If you Brinn believe it's all okay, I'll tell you you're mistaken and mistaken badly. This is not fine and dandy. You'll see.

You need to have the discussion if you are to play this game! Just sitting back and relaxing is both spineless and stupid. You would have had a whole day to discuss things and what do you do? Hide in the shadows so that no one suspects you for standing out and speaking your mind, right?

And I'm kind of serious with this. Just say whatever you say of my role but think yourselves as well what I'm saying: the baddies win when the innocents lay low - and I'd hate to see those dratted rival-baddies win... So pull yourselves together now!

When you think in the late hours of toMorrow that you're in a hurry think of it if you had done something toDay.

It's such an anticlimax to die in a Day like this...

But you carry the consequences toMorrow.

I'm prepared and I have done my best, how about you?

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

Nogrod, you are such a drama queen!

You know very well that given the events that have taken place, the village could have taken no other action than what have been done. We all know that there is a risk that we are being manipulated by evil-doers, but that is a risk we must take.

If you had been in our shoes you would have done the same. . . so please stop the whining.

I agree that more could have been done today, but if there ever was a day to neglect werewolf this was it. Everything have already been decided, so there is not talks that cannot wait until tomorrow.

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by Brinniel

I'm currently working on finding all the quotes by our wolves which mention unknowns, and also finding quotes by the unknowns mentioning wolves. But with nearly 1500 posts on this thread, it's quite the monstrous task and I can already see I won't be finishing by the end of toDay since I'm planning to try to go see Spamalot tonight while it's in town. So all those quotes and an analysis will have to wait until toMorrow..

Anyways, I can't really say my thoughts have changed much since my last analysis post. There hasn't been much posting toDay, and many of the posts there have been are just chatter. I suppose toMorrow it'll be much easier to talk when these naughty boys aren't here to distract us..

So unless I can't get a ticket for the show, I probably won't be back again toDay.

Brinn I certainly advise the village to look at your quotes too.

[Boromir88]

Luckily, after today Nogrod, you'll be dead and your last wolf buddy will not have to cave in to your failed policies from the past 3 days. You got drug around in circles, deal with it.

This could be my last post before the deadline...

Tonight I will either take a look at Rune, Nerwen, or Sally.

Rune for his "visionary" comments about morm, but he's looked more innocent today than yesterday. Especially since yesterday morm tried to get my attention on Rune and not him.


Nerwen, because I'm suspicious of the morm vote for her on Day 2. The "ranger" business could have been easily planned and morm could hope to make himself look better if he was able to get a wolf-Nerwen lynched.

sally...well she's just a little too excited this past day. She seems like she is taking much more joy out of this than anyone else. Maybe she's just loving the opportunity to not live under the oppressive Nogrod regime?

Excluding tp, I feel the best about Lommy and Kath. But of course don't take that as a known statement of their innocence, and if they attempt to argue their innocence because I thought they were, take a good look at them.

Nogrod, this has to of been one of the most productive days ever. We're lynching two wolves and put together a very smooth and nice plan throughout the day. See what happens when you have something called "trust." You should have trusted your packmates' judgement to get rid of me, it was your policies that got you right where you are today, but you continue to blame others.

Now you want to blame Fea for fixing the outcome.

[the phantom]

This day being settled early worked out very nicely for me as I've been extremely busy and will unavailable throughout the evening.

I'll possibly see everyone tomorrow. Unless the final WW has figured out who I am, of course.

[mormegil]

I must get at least 100 posts and tell you the honest truth about who is guilty...oh wait I already have 100 after this...well forget it you're not getting it from me. Besides nobody ever asked nicely.

[Ilya]

So, I read through everything, but there's not all that much to say, other than "Yay us," I suppose. I can't even begin to unravel Nog's shenanigans. The next Day is gonna be sick, y'all.

By the by, what's all this about wolves who can be dreamed ordos and werebears and cobblers? Aren't there just 4 wolves and a seer? Is there some secret set of rules I never saw? Is Fea assigning people new roles every night? Is everybody just kidding?

[Nerwen]

Hello, all. I'll get back to you when I've had time to read through the posts.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

it was your policies that got you right where you are today, but you continue to blame others.

Now you want to blame Fea for fixing the outcome.

I'm not blaming anyone. I'm just alerting the citizens. And if my policies are to blame, well then deal with it. There are policies of opportunism and policies of dignity, policies of the lowest common denominator and policies of chivalry. You choose your side and manner with what you have in your hands, everyone, individually, and you carry that mark with you...

One for the money, two for the show, three for the truth and go wolf go.

Anyway, that's a bit under your stature Boro. Had you been killable you'd not grin around anymore. So thank your mistress for that (do I hear tp getting jealous?). And that's no blame, just a call for being less jubilant with being born with a silver-spoon in your mouth.

I'm somewhow torn about this village. In a way I'd like to see them win over you but on the other hand they seem not to earn it, looking at toDay.

Maybe Fea will balance this out by killing you all...

Originally Posted by Ilya

By the by, what's all this about wolves who can be dreamed ordos and werebears and cobblers? Aren't there just 4 wolves and a seer? Is there some secret set of rules I never saw? Is Fea assigning people new roles every night?

As Fea said, welcome to the advanced game of werewolf. There's no telling what happens or is. This is no elementary game as she underlined it (even if Boro tries to make you believe all is clear - but you'll see it). So everything is possible. Just try to orientate through this and all the conflicting messages... you'll have to decide for yourself what to do in this envirovenment.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Nerwen, because I'm suspicious of the morm vote for her on Day 2. The "ranger" business could have been easily planned and morm could hope to make himself look better if he was able to get a wolf-Nerwen lynched.

Great minds, my friend....

Originally Posted by Boro

sally...well she's just a little too excited this past day. She seems like she is taking much more joy out of this than anyone else. Maybe she's just loving the opportunity to not live under the oppressive Nogrod regime?

Hey, do you realize how often I end up right but don't find out about it until I'm dead? Either that or I pinpoint the wolves and then the village kills me for it? (Not necessarily here, but still....) Besides, I'm a horrible judge of Nog, so calling him indeed does make me a happy girl.


Alternatively....I can't resist. Heh, wasn't it the last game we were in together, Boro? Something involving a dead cobbler come morning although everyone else realized they were evil? *stops poking and guilt tripping*

Alternatively alternatively, I haven't even been reading Nog's posts. Clever clogs over there is undoubtedly causing mischief and I'll not allow him to cloud my judgement on what's going on. (Okay, I've read, but I'm taking it with a grain of salt. Obviously.)



Off for now. Just felt like posting, although I don't have a WHOLE lot to say. Back in a bit perhaps with a list, but if I don't return, sweet dreams, fair village.

[Nerwen]

Earlier toDay I said I'd look at what people were talking about just before morm's half-retraction– All I can find is this:

#1323. [Entire post not quoted]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

Okay, so the last wolf must be among

Brinniel
Gil-Galad
Greenie
Gwathagor
Ilya
Kath
Nerwen
Rune
Sally

[...lists those she thinks are innocent and those she is unsure of]

The wolf could be

Ilya - she has really said some rather fishy stuff and I think she was a bit too quick to trust tp and Boro yesterDay. Also, although I can't recall it right now, I think there's something curious in the relationship between her and Nog...

or

Sally - she seems to have been a little jumpy toDay, which is just understandable if she's about to be left alone. Also, she too says some fishy stuff.


While toDay still lasts, I'd love to have a look at the three wolves' posts and see who looks like their mate and then proceed based on those clues. Also, having a look at at least sally and Ilya separately probably wouldn't do me any bad either. But I doubt I will be much around anymore before the second phase of toDay - I have an exam to study to tonight and I don't feel it's extra necessary that I'm here right now.

The next post is just the phantom discussing his voting-plan.

#1325

Originally Posted by mormegil

Whatever you do, do NOT push this button. Seriously don't dream of Rune it would be a waste of dream.

Then tp posts again about his plan; then we get this:

Originally Posted by mormegil

Jerk!

Oh I confessed did I, ummmm just remember this is a Fea game and anything is possible...*laughs manically*

Comments: well, I think it's safe to say morm was trying to distract us, all right... but perhaps only from the plan to lynch him and Nogrod. Still, there is at least a possibility that Lommy was getting too close to the identity of Wolf #4, who would in that case be either Sally or Ilya.

As for his telling the Seer not to dream of Rune: this is probably reverse psychology. It may be a double- (or do I mean triple?) bluff, of course; however, I don't currently see Rune as particularly wolfish.

EDIT: fixed bolding
EDIT2: and punctuation

[Nogrod]

Eenie-meenie-miny-moe
Lil' Green just hurt her foe
Wimpy-wampy-wumpy-ho
but teepee didn't let her go.
Who's to blame, who's to blame,
asked Boro and turned out lame.

Be-wop-po-loom-wob-bo-lap bam-boom
said Sally just evading her closing doom.
Ilya, Il'y-a? Que est-ce que c'est?
Vous voulez connaitre ce que j'ai fait?
Ka-boom, ka-boom, nanouk, nincompoop!
Lommy thought she was easily off the hoop,
while going the road to sweet Athay haroo, haroo,
Rune managed to make a blunder like a baboon.

Ha-ha,
Frank Zappa
and Jack & Jill went up the hill
with the sh....est group and mormegil
Go round, go down; Go round, go down.

Ha-Ha,
They're coming to take me away hahaa
he-hee, hihii, hohoo, huuhuu...
While Napoleon had nothing to do with that
but the Waterloo neared upon one Gwath...

Or was it a path pointing towards a Kath?
Bibedi-babedi-bou, who knows what's she at?
But I'm Happy to see those nice young men
in their clean white coats, ... uh... Nerwen?
"Liar, liar, see my denial" shouted Brinn, "I'm still in."
"They're coming to take me away, hoho, to the loony bin"

They're coming to take me a way hahaa...
To Antarctica, America, to the Gil-Galad star.

You thought it was joke and so you laughed,
you laughed when I had said that losing you would make me flip my lid,
right?

You know you laughed,
I heard you laugh,
you laughed, you laughed and laughed
and then you left,

but now you know I'm utterly mad.

And they're coming to take me away Ha Ha
They're coming to take me away ho ho he he ha ha

[satansaloser2005]

Nog: Evil or not, you just made my day.

K, back in a bit. I laughed so hard at that post I need my bloody asthma meds. Thanks for that, kiddo.

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

As for his telling the Seer not to dream of Rune: this is probably reverse psychology. It may be a double- (or do I mean triple?) bluff, of course; however, I don't currently see Rune as particularly wolfish.

Seriously a dream of Rune would be a waste or for that matter lynching him would be to so just leave him alone okay, he was kind enough to actually not suspect me...

[mormegil]

Now if I were to start a fillibuster when time expires does the day not end until my fillibuster is over? I could at least prolong my life until then

[Brinniel]

While you may be evil, no one can deny the fact that you are certainly creative, Nogrod.

And yes, I just got back from Spamalot and it was wonderful.

*sings*

Finland, Finland, Finland....the country where I'd quite like to be...

*ahem*

Now back to work...

[Nogrod]

"I cooked your food, I cleaned your house,
and this is how you paid me back for all my kind unselfish loving deeds.
Huh?
Well you just wait they'll find you yet..."

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I'm somewhow torn about this village. In a way I'd like to see them win over you but on the other hand they seem not to earn it, looking at toDay.

You suggest that we should have let you and morm live... even though you've both confessed?

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Maybe Fea will balance this out by killing you all...

That's a thought– has our chief mod-goddess accepted Boro's abortive filibuster, or do we have to provide another?

Nogrod to Ilya:

Originally Posted by Nogrod

As Fea said, welcome to the advanced game of werewolf. There's no telling what happens or is. This is no elementary game as she underlined it (even if Boro tries to make you believe all is clear - but you'll see it). So everything is possible. Just try to orientate through this and all the conflicting messages... you'll have to decide for yourself what to do in this envirovenment.

Nogwolf's parting words to his young apprentice? Or is that what he wants us to think?
EDIT: X'd since my last post.

[Ilya]

Nog: That was quite a piece there, and thanks for the vid because it was hard to deal with before the melody. But this ain't 'Nam. This is WW. There are rules.

Yay, Spamalot! I hear that it's still a great show.

Anyone around who's a Lost geek want to freak out with me over the new footage in the Fray video? I know I'm OTing it, but after the sports breakdown this morning and Nog's mocking me in French, I'm allowed.

EDIT: Aw man, deadline's approaching, nevermind about Lost.

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Ilya

Anyone around who's a Lost geek want to freak out with me over the new footage in the Fray video?

Oooooh.

*goes to watch*

[satansaloser2005]

My top three suspects: Ilya, Nerwen, and....erm....okay make that my top two suspects, because otherwise it's a tie between Brinn and Kath and Rune for a few things they've said toDay (or yesterDay, I'll have to look)



Bwahahahahaha! I shall have the last post, and I shall call it last post, and it shall be my last post. Hehe!

[Rikae]

Deadline, people. Break it up, nothing to see here.

Oh, the lynches: Geil and Boro are dead for discussing football on my watch. Oh, and Nogrod. And not so much Boro.

They were, of course, the seer-leprechaun and the monkey-assassin.

[Mithalwen]

This has been preempted and so you are spared some of the bad jokes I had planned and I may yet get to use the Nogrod death scene I had planned from my last mod game in the next (after Gollum's, auditions opening soon! Plug plug) but having decided that quasi-judicial processes had been done too well by Messrs Formendacil and Pan Man, I couldn't resist a little play with this.

Waiting for Borot

MORMEGIL:
Charming spot. Inspiring prospects. (He turns to Nogrod.) Let's go.

NOGROD:
We can't.

MORMEGIL:
Why not?

NOGROD:
We're waiting for Borot.
…

NOGROD:
There's no good harking back on that. Come on.

He draws him after him. As before.

MORMEGIL:
Wait!

NOGROD:
I'm cold!

MORMEGIL:
Wait! (He moves away from Nogrod.) I sometimes wonder if we wouldn't have been better off alone, each one for himself. (He crosses the stage and sits down on the mound.) We weren't made for the same road.

NOGROD:
(without anger). It's not certain.

MORMEGIL:
No, nothing is certain.

Nogrod slowly crosses the stage and sits down beside Mormegil.

NOGROD:
We can still part, if you think it would be better.

MORMEGIL:
It's not worthwhile now.

Silence.

NOGROD:
No, it's not worthwhile now.

Silence.

MORMEGIL:
Well, shall we go?

NOGROD:
Yes, let's go.

They do not move.

Dead:

Fea
Mith
Rikae
Diamond18 (ordo)
Legate (ordo)
McCaber (ordo)
Eönwë/Steve (ordo)
Aganzir (ordo)
Ka (wolf)
Shasta (ordo)
Mormegil (wolf)
Nogrod (wolf)

Alive:

Boromir88
Brinniel
Gil-Galad
Greenie
Gwathagor
Ilya
Lommy
Kath
Nerwen
Rune
Sally
the phantom

[Rikae]

Lament of the Three Moddesses

Fea:

Through Rohan over fen and field where the long grass
grows
The West Wind comes walking, and about the walls it
goes.
'What news from the West, O wandering wind, do you
bring to me tonight?
Have you seen Boromir who is surnamed eighty-eight?'
'I saw him dream prophetic dreams, over long nights filled with fear;
I saw him talk encrypted words to any that might hear.
He passed then into Shadow. I saw him then no more.
The North Wind may have heard the horn of the son of
Denethor.'
'O Boromir! From the high walls westward I looked
afar,
But you came not from the empty lands where no men
are.'

Mithalwen:

From the mouths of the Sea the South Wind flies, from
the sandhills and the stones;
The howling of the wolf it bears, and at the gate it
moans.
'What news from the South, O sighing wind, do you bring
to me at eve?
Where now is Boromir the Seer? He tarries and I grieve.'
'Ask not of me where he doth dwell -- so many bones
there lie
On the white shores and the dark shores under the
stormy sky;
So many have passed down Anduin to find the flowing
Sea.
Ask of the North Wind news of them the North Wind
sends to me!'
'O Boromir! Beyond the gate the seaward road runs
south,
But Death came thence with the wailing howls from the last
wolf’s mouth.'

Rikae:

From the Gate of Kings the North Wind rides, and past
the roaring falls;
And clear and cold about the tower its loud horn calls.
'What news from the North, O mighty wind, do you
bring to me today?
What news of Boromir the Bold? For he is long away.'
'Beneath Amon Hen I heard his cry. There one last foe he
fought.
His blood alone could avenge the two were-wolves he caught.
His skill too great, his plan so fair, he must be put to rest;
And Rauros, golden Rauros-falls, bore him upon its
breast.'
'O Boromir! The Tower of Guard shall ever northward
gaze
To Rauros, golden Rauros-falls, until the end of days.'

Dead:

Fea
Mith
Rikae
Diamond18 (ordo)
Legate (ordo)
McCaber (ordo)
Eönwë/Steve (ordo)
Aganzir (ordo)
Ka (wolf)
Shasta (ordo)
Mormegil (wolf)
Nogrod (wolf)
Boromir88 (seer)

Alive:

Brinniel
Gil-Galad
Greenie
Gwathagor
Ilya
Lommy
Kath
Nerwen
Rune
Sally
the phantom

[the phantom]

Well, as today is my final day among the living, I'd better make the most of it.

Tomorrow afternoon I'll do a readthrough of everyone left alive and post my thoughts.

And also, don't bother making me a Rep. As I've already been dreamed of my vote isn't going to tell you anything. Currently I am the Ordo who knows the least in this village, as the rest of you Ordos know both your own innocence as well as mine.

Anyway, I'll try and finish my readthroughs and posting my thoughts tomorrow. If I don't get finished in the afternoon I'll make sure and finish it when I get home in the late evening.

[satansaloser2005]

Oh goodness! Boro! How could Boro be dead? He was so young, his death so unexpected, so brutal, and....meh, who am I kidding?




I have a huge paper due that I MUST get working on. Expect tidbits from me along the way but for the next 36 hours I probably won't be posting much. Sorry about that, loves.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Oh goodness! Boro! How could Boro be dead? He was so young, his death so unexpected, so brutal, and....meh, who am I kidding?

Stop gloating, wolfisaloser.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Stop gloating, wolfisaloser.

Oi! Only Nog's allowed to call me that. ()



Although if that's what you and your packmates called me when you spoke of me during the Nights, by all means, I don't want to disrupt tradition.

[Nerwen]

I should have said this in my first post:

R.I.P. Boromir88. You died like a true son of Gondor... and in the process annoyed the wolves so much that one of them went raving mad and another voted against your fictional namesake in the Middle Earth Popularity Cup. We'll build you a statue next to Shasta's.

You still around, Sally? In all seriousness, you are one of my suspects for Wolf #4. However, I've never been good at reading you, so if you have any thoughts you want to share I'm willing to listen.

[A Little Green]

Hmmm. I'm here again, probably making a list in a minute. Ah well. *back soon*

[Nerwen]

Guess who's here?

[A Little Green]

So the last wolf is one of these guys:
Brinniel
Gil-Galad
Gwathagor
Ilya
Lommy
Kath
Nerwen
Rune
Sally

POSSIBLE:
Gil-Galad - If it's him, I'll be very disappointed with the game indeed.
Gwathagor - I'll look at him if I have time. I have no idea at all about him.
Ilya - I'm slightly wary about her at the moment.
Sally - I don't know. There is something about her that makes me somewhat uneasy.

IMPROBABLE:
Brinniel - I don't find her suspicious.
Lommy - Not suspicious.
Kath - I don't think it's her.
Nerwen - Doesn't strike me as suspicious.
Rune - Seems innocentish.
(How many ways can I invent of saying someone looks innocent, I wonder.)

I'm worried about how my arguments have gone worse and worse all the time. I had some pretty good ones a few Days ago, and look at them now. "Slightly wary" or "Something about her makes me slightly uneasy". I need to (I accidentally wrote "I need tp"... ) look at the thread to find something a bit more constructive to say.
Just to clear it - those on my "possible"-list are not people I find suspicious but rather people I don't find innocentish. People I'll keep an eye on. People whose posting I will look at if I have the time, which I probably don't - I should be studying Swedish at the moment and not playing WW...

However if Nerwen is around (), or someone else, I might stay a while and chat. It's so much nicer to post if there is someone else around too.


EDIT: x-ed with Nerwen

[A Little Green]

So Nerwen dear, who do you suspect is the fourth wolf? It seems Sally is one of your suspects, who are the others?

[Nerwen]

Unfortunately, the same as your list of "possibles"– except that I really don't have any idea about Gwath (and I'm half-inclined to put you on it too, Lily, just because I know how sneaky you can be).

One thing that I've been thinking is that the wild performances by Nogwolf and Wolfegil might have been inspired by their desperation at leaving everything in the paws of a newbie, i.e. Ilya.

Also, Nogwolf gave Ilya what looked like parting advice in his last post. I wouldn't want to read too much into that, though, not when morm had already addressed half the village as fellow-wolves.