WW LXI: Grimm Tales

[Mirandir]

Originally Posted by the phantom

I suggest we lynch no one.

And where, dear phantom, is the fun in that?

Ima go ahead and vote now since it probably should be bedtime (meaning I'll vote now and retract later if necessary when there's actually reason to do so). So for now,

++sally

Since I know she won't hurt me for voting her.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Agan

Well if she isn't sure of her participation tomorrow and doesn't want to risk modfire? In that case I understand.

Well yes I considered that option but it's still not a vote I'd have made...

Originally Posted by McCab

If someone wants tp dead fast, they have an excellent start on it.

I could bet almost anything for that he's going to retract that vote...

What's thing between phantom and Nienna?

Originally Posted by Shasta

And one suggestion for the village; lynch Phantom or Boro today. If both of them are around for too long, this game will go from "confusing" to "mind-numbingly complicated".

Haha, so true. But I just think we should ignore them to an extent, especially tp.

I have a feeling everybody's sending hints all the time and I'm not getting them.

I will now go to sleep, unless I've cross-posted with something interesting...

PS. Feel free to lynch me for I also think beer is bad.


edit: xed with Boro's #72 and everything after that

[wilwarin538]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Basically that's not a good thing to say for an ordo since it narrows down the field of possible Red Caps and therefore makes it easier for the Big Bad Wolf to guess her identity.

Little Red doesn't know who she is. She was told she was an ord. ("she" referring to role, not necessarily player, as always)

Oh, and I'm Canadian and I don't even like beer. So feel free to lynch me....oh wait. :P

[Kath]

Shall we have a list? I think we shall! I suspect most of the entries will simply say 'banter' but there's not a lot I can do about that at this stage.

Nerwen - do Agan and Lommy fight a lot in game? I hadn't noticed that before, or at least not remembered it.

Eomer - banter.

Lommy - clearly Noggie is playing over her shoulder with the loud/quiet debate comment. Thinks Lari should have refrained from voting, but would likely have been the first to jump on her and ask why she hadn't voted if Lari had gone for that option. From her list has some suspicion of Lari based on what she said before, otherwise she's no idea. Ah we have a retraction! Well that explains Boro.

Agan - I want to know how many other people are now tempted to go look up all Nerwen's past games and see if that thing about the word 'terrible' is true! Warns of potential revenge vote. Very good point about the fair maiden if her maths is right. Loud/quiet debate. Doesn't like Boro or phantom but will leave them alone - reason?

sally - pops up.

McCaber - surprisingly well thought out suspicions for a first post! Adds to the loud/quiet debate.

Mira - appears.

Shasta - arrives. Says McCaber is always quiet and we should kill phantom and/or Boro now to save ourselves a headache.

Gwath - says Boro should be able to test the village without resorting to killing.

Boro - whole lot of nothing. This list on the other hand not so well thought out. *sigh* And off to coded communication again. I knew there was a reason I hated Boro and phantom playing together. Votes phantom, I'm sure for some horrendously complicated reason. This early in the game I don't much care to try and pick it apart.

Inzil - intro post. Haha! I love his (boy yes?) description of phantom: a bit unbalanced and unpredictable? Just you wait til Fea begins her madness Inzil.

Nienna - banter.

Greenie - arrives ... leaves. Doesn't like the unreasoned votes against phantom.

Lari - makes her excuses and leaves, voting phantom first. I can see her point. It's like the people who vote Nog early on Day 1 only to see him saved in the last few seconds.

Mith - arrives. Wonders about the votes for phantom. Seems to have come to no real conclusions but clearly thinking things through well. Not keen on Boro or Lommy.

phantom - random except for the mention of Lari. Interesting thoughts, but there are also 4 ordos on the 'normal' Gifted team. Helpfully suggests we lynch no one. If there were no wolves fine, but as there are it isn't a great plan.

And I got nothing from Izzy, Gaurcrist or Fea. Though I foresee problems with me realising Fea has arrived because I thought she had already before I realised it was actually Greenie.

From all that the only person who jumped out at me was Lommy for her reaction to Lari's vote. I'm going to vote in a few minutes so it'll probably be for her.

[Kath]

Hmm cross posted with quite a few people there.

[Mithalwen]

Wilwa dear that was not a helpful clarification...

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by wilwarin538

Little Red doesn't know who she is. She was told she was an ord. ("she" referring to role, not necessarily player, as always)

I know but as anyone who thinks xe's an ordo could be her, it isn't good to be too loud about being ordinary.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Shasta

Oh well. I suppose I'll just have to vote for Boromir first.

Do what you will, but I repeat, my books say Boro has a girl role. And in this world, there are more good girls than bad ones.

In this world.

Anyway, I can understand being upset with Shasta for admitting he's an Ordo. The best thing an Ordo can do in this set up is get themselves Night-killed or guessed by the baddies. But oh well. The fact that his play upsets us doesn't make him any less of an Ordo. So everyone should just leave him be.

Originally Posted by Gwath

Safe from you? What would you to to us if we weren't?

Night kill you.

I mean- no, um, lynch you is what I meant to say.

Originally Posted by Mith

Can you all stop hitting on me. I am so not in the mood....

I know what will cheer you up, dear. I'll make you the goal-keeper on the TIG team.

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by the phantom

I know what will cheer you up, dear. I'll make you the goal-keeper on the TIG team.

++ the phantom

Not because I think you are evil but because you are patronising and I hate you.

[Kath]

++LOMMY

For the reasons mentioned above. I won't be back before deadline now.

[wilwarin538]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Wilwa dear that was not a helpful clarification...

Yes, uhm...I realised that after I said it. I misunderstood what Agan was trying to say. Just ignore me.....

[Thinlómien]

Kath, you're right, I realise that now. I would have condemned Lari if she had popped up and said she isn't going to vote. And also if she had voted someone and claimed it's random. And possibly even is she had voted herself. Oh well.

edit: xed with Mith, Kath and Wilwa

[Mirandir]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

++ the phantom

Not because I think you are evil but because you are patronising and I hate you.

I'm sensing some hostility here. Can't we all just get along and play a nice clean game of WW?

...

Oh who am I kidding?

And yes, I really do have nothing of substance to contribute at the moment. Although the hostility between Mith and phantom has been noted.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Mithypoo

Not because I think you are evil but because you are patronising and I hate you.

"Patronising"?! How dare you call me patronising, you insignificant piece of dust! You're all just little mole-hills compared to Mount Phantom the mighty!! I am all-pow....

Wait.... oh, okay. I can see that argument, Mith. Sorry.

Originally Posted by Lommy

What's thing between phantom and Nienna?

She is my bitter rival. Rival because we both own bookshops. Bitter because her boyfriends always dump her. But that really has nothing to do with the question.

[Boromir88]

Boro - whole lot of nothing. This list on the other hand not so well thought out. *sigh* And off to coded communication again. I knew there was a reason I hated Boro and phantom playing together. Votes phantom, I'm sure for some horrendously complicated reason. This early in the game I don't much care to try and pick it apart.~Kath

I take greater joy out of people thinking I have a brilliant concoction, and giving people a headache, when there is no reason to, because I have no plan and I just say random things that come to mind.

Now for the reason I voted for tp, you have already figured it out, see Miss Cleo...now that is an intentional coded message directed at you, because if I were to tell you the answer directly it won't work.

wilwa, aren't you supposed to be dead?

Mira, aren't you supposed to be in bed?

Mith...as....you...wish *picture me saying that as I roll off a cliff.*

[Mirandir]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Mira, aren't you supposed to be in bed?

*cough* Nooo...

[Boromir88]

Originally Posted by Mirandir

*cough* Nooo...

Ok then, in that case, before you actually do go to sleep, I hope you are not shirking any duties, just make sure if you have something important to remember, please remember to do it.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Because such a thing as good beer does not exist? My taste is just too sophisticated for beer.

WHAAAT? You - what - how could - ridiculous!! I am at a loss for suitable words and refuse to talk to you for the rest of the game - or until I feel so inclined, whichever comes sooner. I will only say this: my sense of taste is QUITE sophisticated and I enjoy certain kinds of beer VERY much. You speak evil of that which is fair beyond the reach of your thought, and only little wit can excuse you!

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Kath

do Agan and Lommy fight a lot in game? I hadn't noticed that before, or at least not remembered it.

Erm check every game we've played together since the Duelling Wizards.
I blame Rikae though, she told us wolves to lynch Lommy so I made a massive case against her, and it sort of stuck.

Originally Posted by Kath

Doesn't like Boro or phantom but will leave them alone - reason?

It wasn't a very serious don't-like yet. Anyway I usually leave those twain alone on day 1 and wait till I can develop a clearer picture of them because everyone is concentrating on them all the time anyway.

I like also Kath for now.

Anyway my brain is slowing down so I'll go to sleep. Good night.

edit: xed with Boro & Gwath.

[Mirandir]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Ok then, in that case, before you actually do go to sleep, I hope you are not shirking any duties, just make sure if you have something important to remember, please remember to do it.

Yes Mommy.

I certainly hope I don't have anything important to remember...My alarm is set for the morning and I put on clean underwear so I think everything's set.

Yay 400th post!

[wilwarin538]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

wilwa, aren't you supposed to be dead?

Yes, this is my spirit here to comfort you through this terrible ordeal. Didn't you read my narration?

I'm just bored, and all of this amuses me, which makes me less bored. And I'm expecting some PMs from certain peoples.

[Boromir88]

Yes Mommy.~Mira

You know I wasn't understanding why tp is convinced that I have a girl's role, I guess that just proves it. I walked straight into that one.

I'm just bored, and all of this amuses me, which makes me less bored. And I'm expecting some PMs from certain peoples.~wilwa

I hope you find what you seek. It must be really amusing knowing who's what...I am very jealous right now.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Ok then, in that case, before you actually do go to sleep, I hope you are not shirking any duties, just make sure if you have something important to remember, please remember to do it.

Trying to pass Mira off as a gifted so the wolves will kill her, eh?

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Someone want to enlighten me as to when deadline is, so I don't forget to vote?

[wilwarin538]

In 12 hours, in relation to your post.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Ewwwwww, eight in the morning? Sadness.

I'll just have to vote a couple hours early, that's all.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

I've arrived.

Fashionably late, of course.

Everybody knows my first day feelings: nobody's done anything particularly naughty yet, so nobody really has anything to hide, ergo nobody has any reason at all to be acting suspiciously, so any suspicions are pure bunk, created with poor reasoning and no legitimate evidence based on fact.

Consequently: I think we should lynch the phantom today, just because I seem to remember he's never been lynched, and I'd hate to deprive him of the honor of an early demise.

[Boromir88]

Ok so first day is past half way, and it is now time for me to get serious. You can ignore everything I have said before this point, so if anyone would ever wish to do an analysis on me, you should start with this post. (Or I guess the post after this one, because this is just a post telling everyone I mean business - not the actual business yet.)

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Kath

Inzil - intro post. Haha! I love his (boy yes?) description of phantom: a bit unbalanced and unpredictable? Just you wait til Fea begins her madness Inzil.

I was spot on the phantom, hmm? And Feanor is one to watch? I seem to be surrounded by devious characters, all with their own little schemes. If that's not a good time, I don't know what is.
I still have no particular feeling on a suspect at this point. Boromir has said some odd things, either playing mind games or possibly something more ominous, but now he says that was all in fun.
Mith and the phantom appear to have a little animosity toward one another; Gwathagor seems ok, as (he?) likes beer; Aganzir 'doesn't hold with beer' (casts sidelong glance)........
I'm going to bed now, but I'll be up well in time for the deadline. Maybe something will come together by morning (probably wishful thinking).

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

I vote we lynch all the beer-drinkers and leave the village to the ones who are happy to drink whiskey straight.

[Inziladun]

I just noticed I didn't answer Kath's question. I am indeed, male.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Feanor of the Peredhil

I vote we lynch all the beer-drinkers and leave the village to the ones who are happy to drink whiskey straight.

Seconded!

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Fea

I think we should lynch the phantom today, just because I seem to remember he's never been lynched

No, no, dear, I was lynched in WW III. Been there, done that.

And I have no opinion on the lynch-beer-drinkers debate. I'm a Dr Pepper man.

I agree, Boro, that we really ought to be getting serious now, but my role is just so fun. I'm usually analyzing and scheming and other things, when it's much easier and fun to just thrash about and say stuff for no reason at all. I should be a slightly insane book liberator in every village.

Plus I don't really have time to do much of anything, not to mention that there isn't much to analyze at this point. I'll get serious later. Day 2 maybe. For sure by Day 3. Because really, folks, this is a fairy tale village. I've read enough of those to know that we'll all live happily ever after. So why stress? Go home, and read a book. But not one of mine.

*pets books*

I'm going to take a nap now. Okay, not really- I'm actually going to grab my equipment and attempt to rob Nienna's store while everyone is preoccupied with this Werewolf stuff. But shhh, you don't know anything about it.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Feanor of the Peredhil

I vote we lynch all the beer-drinkers and leave the village to the ones who are happy to drink whiskey straight.

But what will you do with those who drink both?

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Gwathagor

But what will you do with those who drink both?

(I am presuming that for the purposes of this debate you aren't differentiating between whiskey and whisky.)

[McCaber]

Well, I'm back. And Watchmen is still an awesome movie, for all those concerned.

Beer vs. Whiskey, eh? I think I'm with tp here, but I favor the Jones Cream Soda myself.

Fea's playing around with her first few posts. Nothing wrong with that, as long as it stays playing.

(psst, phantom, if you need any "breaking and entering" kits, they're around back of the shop.)

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Mira, Mira, on the wall

And where, dear phantom, is the fun in that?

Ima go ahead and vote now since it probably should be bedtime (meaning I'll vote now and retract later if necessary when there's actually reason to do so). So for now,

++sally

Since I know she won't hurt me for voting her.

Oh really?! Here, have an apple, darling.

Originally Posted by Queen Mith

++ the phantom

Not because I think you are evil but because you are patronising and I hate you.

And in a dramatic reversal....

Wow, I'm tempted to lynch phantom just to see if we could actually get him lynched on Day One. Of course this would do us no good so I probably wouldn't actually do it, but still....it'd make me giggle.

Originally Posted by Bad News Boro

I take greater joy out of people thinking I have a brilliant concoction, and giving people a headache, when there is no reason to, because I have no plan and I just say random things that come to mind.

Mith...as....you...wish *picture me saying that as I roll off a cliff.*

Always a good choice, Boro dear. And may I just say....very nice....

Originally Posted by Prince Gwath

Trying to pass Mira off as a gifted so the wolves will kill her, eh?

Agan's not the only one misreading things.....*shifty eyes*



K, so I had a bunch of stuff quoted earlier (like things I wanted to properly respond to) but my internet's been even more horrible than usual. I really did mean to post this afternoon, and tried several times, but I haven't had internet since my last post, at least not for long enough to make a post. With that in mind I have no idea who to vote but want to make sure I do vote, so....


++Agan


Because of a weird feeling, and because I know she won't get cross with me for voting her out of desperation. I'll do my best to catch up with the thread, but honestly I don't think I'll be back for the rest of the Day because I'll likely go to bed the next time my internet kicks out, which will be shortly.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Gwathagor

(I am presuming that for the purposes of this debate you aren't differentiating between whiskey and whisky.)

No differentiation at all. Though I should specify that shooting whiskey isn't the same as drinking it.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Feanor of the Peredhil

No differentiation at all.

Good to hear.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

I'm going to bed in a few minutes, and I am not waking up to vote before deadline. No way.

So

++Boromir88

For teasing Mira about going to bed and making it sound like she was staying up in order to do Gifted-y things. And/or hinting at her that she's his Lover and ought to PM Wilwa about it asap so that they can rule the world together after killing us all. Or something. Dear god I'm tired.

Yeah.

Dear Day 1: the day you start offering me legitimate options, I will start voting with better rationale.