Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Who still has to vote and which way are you tending?

Mac - I have two votes ...can you amend your list to show ?

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

I'm confused. You find Lal most suspicious but are choosing to vote someone else? (Never mind that it's me. Heh you ungrateful son of a Sycorax. ) (Sally)

Cos, she be Cobbler, and I don't want her stealing my vote-gathering limelight.

Enedwaith, really sorry, but I really no serious suspicions (aside from the aforementioned Cobblery-Lal), so:

++satansaloser2005

[Nogrod]

I would prefer Boro, Lal or Sally

[Macalaure]

I suppose a last minute run at Boromir isn't going to happen?

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Her .... am tempted but she is very young so a big commitment ... had thought could cope with a venerable cat who had given up hunting and just wants food ,warmth, comfort and a bit of fuss.... we'll see.

OT - keep her as a house cat and she'll be no bother - go for it, kitties need nice mums!!!

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

Cos, she be Cobbler, and I don't want her stealing my vote-gathering limelight.

Enedwaith, really sorry, but I really no serious suspicions (aside from the aforementioned Cobblery-Lal), so:

++satansaloser2005

Now that's just not nice. Didn't your mommy ever teach you to share with the other hobbitses?


EDIT: my comment is in response to the first line of Nilp's post, not his vote. Just so it's clear as mud.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

Cos, she be Cobbler, and I don't want her stealing my vote-gathering limelight.

Cobbler-candidate #4.

*whimpers*

[Nogrod]

I'm afraid not even if I would join. Sadly it would kill me...

[Mithalwen]

But not fair to keep inside when we has lovely garden my precious ... but have spent catless years encouraging birdies ... may go for the cowbell route...

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

Cos, she be Cobbler, and I don't want her stealing my vote-gathering limelight.

Is this War of the Psephologists then?

[Nogrod]

++ Sally

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Cobbler-candidate #4.

*whimpers*

My thoughts exactly.


I x'd with Nog's last post but quote it anyway (yay for recent replies at the bottom)

I'm afraid not even if I would join. Sadly it would kill me...

Selfish son of a mother.

[Macalaure]

I'm tempted to vote both Mith and Lal for going off-topic that way right before the deadline.


*sigh*

Let's hope the best with this:

++satansaloser2005

[Mithalwen]

All this and now my parenting is questioned....

[Durelin]

Day has ended.

satansaloser2005 has been lynched; she was a Werewolf.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

++ Sally

Bugger.


Well, parting words then? If I may?

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

I'm tempted to vote both Mith and Lal for going off-topic that way right before the deadline.


*sigh*

Let's hope the best with this:

++satansaloser2005

sorry .. bit demob happy and we have both voted...

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Bugger.


Well, parting words then? If I may?

Blast. Didn't mean to submit that. Oh well.




Friends, Gallifreyans, countrymen, lend me your ears.

"Avenge my foul and most unnatural murder." And I say this to....

....

....

....

....




....My lovely wolf partner. I won't make you all suffer. *dies* Enjoy the game!

~~Sally~~



EDIT: x'd with Durelin, who ruined my fun. *dies again and stays that way*

[Durelin]

Night 4 is over.

Day 4 has begun.

Rikae has been killed. She was an Ordinary Innocent.

Start talking!

Here's the list...really quite blah of me not to give it to you as it's certainly helpful!


~The Dead~

Leonard Nimoy (Half-Vulcan) ~ illogically murdered by the wolves
CaptainofDespair (Wererat) ~ Crushed on Day 1 to reveal his Dark Side
Day One (Evil Wizard) ~ Brought down alongside the might of Cluny the Scourge
Kath (Ordinary Innocent) ~ Tortured and ripped apart by the wolves on Night 2
Gwathagor (Ordinary Innocent) ~ Assassinated by con-goers on Day 2.
Brinniel (Ordinary Innocent) ~ Made really dead on Night 3.
satansaloser2005 (Werewolf)
Rikae (Ordinary Innocent)


~The Living~

Nerwen - Jedi Master, specializing in memorabilia collecting and movie quoting
Feanor of the Peredhil - Rabid Cosmo fan and TOS-TNG Trekkie with opinions
Boromir88 - Fireworks Pyro and Sean Bean's #1 fan
Nilpaurion Felagund - Noldo with a zanpakutou named Telpelin and the Mangekyou Sharingan
Nogrod - "Spore" anticipator who wants to play Eru
McCaber - Old School RPer
Shastanis Althreduin - Rabid Hermione Fan-wizard
Mithalwen - Confused hardcore Tolkienista who thought she was going to Oxonmoot
Isabellkya - Rabid fan of Vampire Princess Miyu
Lalwendë - "In The Night Garden" Fan-mother
Macalaure - "Civilization" fan with Machiavellian tendencies

[Lalwendë]

Just time to post up the votes before I go and serve up my middle class chicken and chips (being chicken wrapped in bacon with roast potatoes ).

Kath (Deceased) - Brinn / n/a
CoD (Deceased) - Day 1 / n/a
Gwath (deceased) - Rikae / Nogrod / n/a
Brinn (Deceased) - Mac / Sally / n/a
Sally (deceased) - Boro / Nogrod / Nogrod
Rikae (deceased) - Sally / McCaber / Sally
Nerwen - ??? / Boro / Boro
Fea - Boro / Boro / Mith
Boro - Lal / Lal / Lal
Nilp - ??? / Gwath / Sally
Nogrod - Gwath / Gwath / Sally
McCaber - CoD / Sally / Sally
Shasta - Boro / ??? / Nogrod
Mith - CoD / Gwath / Lal
Isabellkya - CoD / Nogrod / Nogrod
Lalwendë - Brinn / McCaber / Mith

Mac - CoD / Gwath / Sally

[Mithalwen]

Ah I was wondering how you could tell if a chicken were middle class, I had thought you meant it knew which cutlery it should be eaten with. I am going to read through again in the light of Rikae's death. The only thought I have fromskimming at lunchtime is better not shared for now.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Boromir, do you want me to vote for Lal today?

[Mithalwen]

Don't vote for me again will you darling, it really isn't helpful.... assuming you are on the side of the angels rather than a cobbler asking a wolf for instructions -which would be a tad blatant even for you...

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Don't vote for me again will you darling, it really isn't helpful.... assuming you are on the side of the angels rather than a cobbler asking a wolf for instructions -which would be a tad blatant even for you...

Well at least at this point you know that if nothing else, I'm not a wolf asking another wolf for instructions.

And don't worry, I don't actually want to lynch you. I won't stop the village if they try it, but I won't be joining the party.

[Mithalwen]

Well as the man said I would not be the greatest loss.... but... I will go and play while the great ones discuss high matters....

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Well as the man said I would not be the greatest loss.... but... I will go and play while the great ones discuss high matters....

Hope you're not considering me to be one of the great ones... I wouldn't know a high matter if it hallucinated at me.

[Mithalwen]

cognoscenti if you prefer....

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Lalwendë

Just time to post up the votes before I go and serve up my middle class chicken and chips (being chicken wrapped in bacon with roast potatoes ).

Kath (Deceased) - Brinn / n/a
CoD (Deceased) - Day 1 / n/a
Gwath (deceased) - Rikae / Nogrod / n/a
Brinn (Deceased) - Mac / Sally / n/a
Sally (deceased) - Boro / Nogrod / Nogrod
Rikae (deceased) - Sally / McCaber / Sally
Nerwen - ??? / Boro / Boro
Fea - Boro / Boro / Mith
Boro - Lal / Lal / Lal
Nilp - ??? / Gwath / Sally
Nogrod - Gwath / Gwath / Sally
McCaber - CoD / Sally / Sally
Shasta - Boro / ??? / Nogrod
Mith - CoD / Gwath / Lal
Isabellkya - CoD / Nogrod / Nogrod
Lalwendë - Brinn / McCaber / Mith
Mac - CoD / Gwath / Sally

I was surprised at Sally - though she did get a bit panicky at the end there - and I suppose if minds aren't already made up and you dare risk being close to deadline, then that's a good place to find a wolf. Alas, I may have to get a vote in early tomorrow due to being busy so I might not get to give that a bash.

Anyway, obvious things from the above list.... If we do not have wolf-on-wolf voting....

Not Sus: Nilp, Nogrod, McCaber, Mith, Isabellkya, Mac
Sus: Nerwen, Fea, Boro, Shasta

However, it all depends on whether or not there has been WoW votes, and there's a strong case for that. Though I think we could eliminate those who have multiple votes to lynch wolves. McCaber and Mac are therefore definitely good guys! And I don't think I'll be listening with two ears if anyone else claims to be the Seer

[Boromir88]

Boromir, do you want me to vote for Lal today?~Fea

If you think it would be beneficial, than go ahead...but I have a feeling she's not the last wolf, she's the tricksy cobbler.

I'm not quite sure why you're happy to still see me alive, but I'm not complaining.

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Mith

Ah I was wondering how you could tell if a chicken were middle class, I had thought you meant it knew which cutlery it should be eaten with.

That's if it's an Organic one - it practically comes out of the wrapping with a copy of the Guardian under it's plucked wing. I added Lancashire cheese between pig and hen and it turned out very nicely anyway...

Originally Posted by Boromir88

I have a feeling she's not the last wolf.

Must be a strong one, what what?

[Macalaure]

Rikae is dead? You... you... there are no words in Entish, Elvish, or the tongues of Men (that would not get deleted from a mod) for this!

Well, I guess it doesn't make much sense to bemoan her death now. Only one wolf left while both gifteds and many ordos are still alive. That sounds like pretty good odds for us, but that one wolf needs to be caught still. With Rikae's death and all the stuff that happened near the deadline, I think I have a few opinions to revise now.

[Mithalwen]

Guardian is more lefty, Islington pseudo intelligentsia middle-class traitors - make it the Telegraph and source chook from Waitrose....

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Rikae is dead? You... you... there are no words in Entish, Elvish, or the tongues of Men (that would not get deleted from a mod) for this!

.

Calm down dear! It is only a game. And she did pick up on Sally before anyone else which may have been a factor if the last wolf followed Sally's request.

The odds are good but if the last wolf is among the quieter souls then it may be hard to spot them. :S Night kills may end up being the clues and that is not ideal. Of course with the seer and ranger it makes it harder for them because if they think they have spotted the seer there is a good chance the ranger will spot the same signs and they then have to decide whether to risk it.

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Guardian is more lefty, Islington pseudo intelligentsia middle-class traitors - make it the Telegraph and source chook from Waitrose....

Actually, yeah, no chicken would be seen... errr... dead with a copy of the Guardian. Now, if it was a piece of Quorn in a Jamie Oliver sauce, now you're talking

[Nogrod]

Now where are the celebrations?

One wolf left (and the cobbler) in a village of 11 with the seer and ranger still alive! So 1-10 in counting the outcome, or 2-9 in intentions or alignments, which means we have about five Days to find the last wolf.

We can't lose this. Or if we do... then we shall have to blame our incapability for the wolf has really a hard time to survive now alone.

I'm going to look back at yesterDay and will promise not to make such a gigantic post I made yesterDay of it.

[Macalaure]

The fact that the votes were so spread and we still got a wolf is interesting.

Rikae -> Sally
Shasta -> Nogrod (not a surprise, he's been after him for a while)
Boro -> Lal (no surprise at all)
Fea -> Mith (not commenting on Fea at all now, though I wish I could - let the wolf figure her out alone)
Lal -> Mith (made sense from her point of view)
Izzy -> Nogrod (this vote might be shady)
McCaber -> Sally (consistently after her. If he's a wolf, he's the most lupocidal one ever)
Mith -> Lal (again, made sense from her point of view)
Nerwen -> Boro (see below)
Sally -> Nogrod (this vote puts Nogrod into a pretty good light, there were so many other choices to vote for)
Nilp -> Sally (very innocent vote)
Nogrod -> Sally (self-preservation)
me -> Sally (out of all Sally-votes, probably the least innocent-looking)

Well, that was less yielding than I thought... the remaining wolf is making his/her cases well, I suppose. Judging by vote placement only, the people who gave a second vote to not-Sally are the most suspicious: Lal, Izzy, Mith. Nerwen is, too: the way she voted, it's a throwaway. If you start something new close to the deadline, you have to be active and get others to follow. She didn't.

I will look at what can be learned from Rikae and Sally later.

Originally Posted by Mith

Calm down dear! It is only a game.

Actually, I was half-joking there. *needs to use more smileys*

[Mithalwen]

Rikae really wants me dead. Why? (Not that I'm complaining, she's not succeeded yet, but she's after me like no other. I wonder....blah, have to talk about that later)Sally posted this yesterday.

Maybe the last wolf thought that she was the Seer.

Mac..I know that - there was an annoying car insurance commercial here where someone gets very agitated about their car being hit and is told "Calm down dear, it's only a commercial"....

[Mithalwen]

Have to leave soon.... anyone out there before I say goodbye?

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Rikae really wants me dead. Why? (Not that I'm complaining, she's not succeeded yet, but she's after me like no other. I wonder....blah, have to talk about that later)Sally posted this yesterday.

Maybe the last wolf thought that she was the Seer.

Mac..I know that - there was an annoying car insurance commercial here where someone gets very agitated about their car being hit and is told "Calm down dear, it's only a commercial"....

Michael Winner creeps into WW? Meh.

It wasn't just Rikae who wanted Sally dead so you could be right there, as why would she pick on Rikae? Though Rikae had flown right under the radar yesterday so she was probably a really easy meal. There will almost certainly be no traces but I'm going to look anyway.

I was hoping to bung more on tonight but I had to go and help clean up baby vomit. And then change all the sheets. And put baby vests to soak and so on. And I found Shelob dead inside the duvet cover. Eyuw.

[Nogrod]

Okay and here we go again... (I see Mac has done about the same thing but well, now we havew two accounts of yesterDay's voting. Interesting to see if they differ...

Rikae -> Sally
(01.39)
For her voting mainly… also her other posting.

Sally1

Shasta -> Nogrod
(06.23)
“I didn't like Nog yesterday, I would have voted him yesterday, and he's done nothing to assuage my suspicions today.”

Sally1, Nogrod1

Boro -> Lalwendë
(15.32)
After an intensive and consistent campaign against her.

Sally1, Nogrod1, Lalwendë1

Fëa -> Mith
(15.59)
“Sorry, darling. You know I love you, but...” Only her second post of the Day. Very early on the Day she said: “I could see a Mithwolf in this game...” but that’s all.

Nogrod1, Lalwendë1, Mith1

Lal -> Mith
(16.28)
After a whole Day of a row with her.

Sally1, Nogrod1, Lalwendë1, Mith2

Izzy -> Nogrod
(16.34)
“Crap gotta go. Just when things took a turn, oh dear.” Was consistent though.

Sally1, Nogrod1, Lalwendë1, Mith2

McCaber -> Sally
(16.38)
Had been consistently suspecting Sally for her Day1 voting trying to save CoD (which we now know was a correct idea).

Sally2, Nogrod1, Lalwendë1, Mith2

Mith -> Lalwendë
(16.40)
“Anyway wish I could get a woluf but surviving and a cobbler would do for today.” And we know how they were fighting yesterday anyway.

Sally2, Nogrod1, Lalwendë2, Mith2

Nerwen -> Boro
(16.40)
“I was having a serious think about voting for the de facto cobbler– that's what Lalwendë is, whatever her official role– just to get her out of the way”. Has suspected Boro from his Day1 vote onwards, consistently votes him even if discussed him yesterday not too much (one comment that is).

Sally2, Nogrod2, Lalwendë2, Mith2, Boro1

Sally -> Nogrod
(16.52)
“Again, of my suspects he's top of the list. I wouldn't mind a Lal lynch either, but at the moment I've got bigger Finns, erm fish, to fry.” Is being consistent though.

Sally2, Nogrod3, Lalwendë2, Mith2, Boro1

Nilp -> Sally
(16.55)
Said he didn’t have any serious suspicions but that of Lal the Cobbler.

Sally3, Nogrod3, Lalwendë2, Mith2, Boro1

Nogrod -> Sally
(17.00)
She was one of my top candidates but there were obvious reasons why I chose her from the other possibilities…

Sally4, Nogrod3, Lalwendë2, Mith2, Boro1

Mac -> Sally
(17.00)
“I'm tempted to vote both Mith and Lal for going off-topic that way right before the deadline.” Wished to get Boro lynched. Sally was her suspicion number two (shared place with Nilp).

Sally5, Nogrod3, Lalwendë2, Mith2, Boro1