Visit The *EVEN NEWER* Barrow-Downs Photo Page |
09-19-2003, 11:58 AM | #1 |
Wight
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Laurelindorenan
Posts: 225
|
Aragorn's mistake concerning the army raised from the Paths of the Dead
The army that Aragorn raised from the Paths of the Dead was said to be the most mortiferous army on M.E., and that no other force could rival it when raised by that who will wield Narsil reforged...
So... why not continuing the victory achieved in the Pelennor Fields with the aid of the Dead Army and go straight directly to Mordor to destroy Sauron's armies? Imagine taking the forces of Gondor, the forces of Rohan, the forces of all the other allies and the Dead Army... They would not have depended on the destruction of the One Ring to destroy Mordor's forces... they would wip out the menace that Sauron's forces are... and even if Frodo failed, the worst thing that could happen was that Sauron would be vanished, not destroyed... and even probably Gandalf and the other forces of Good (Aragorn, Eomer, Elrond, Galadriel) would wip all the evil out of Mordor... And eventually destroy the One Ring after regaining it from Frodo... I never understood that... And if it was really a mistake from Aragorn, his error almost costed the future freedom of M.E. What do you think?
__________________
"In place of a Dark Lord you will have a Queen! Not dark but beatiful and terrible as the Dawn! Treacherous as the sea! Stronger than the foundations of the Earth! All shall love me and despair!" --- Galadriel when tempted by the One Ring. |
09-19-2003, 12:33 PM | #2 |
Brightness of a Blade
|
Well, I think that to use the Dark army against Sauron to overthrow him and destroy the Ring would have been a deed worthy of Sauron himself. That is, Aragorn couldn't and did not want to use such soldiers, such ;wraiths of fear and darkness' that evoked a nameless fear, not only in his enemies, but in his allies as well. It would have been no telling the good side from the bad side then.
In addition, I don't think that the dead would have it this way. My understanding was that they were summoned only for a single battle, which makes it a truly hard for Aragorn to decide which battle this would be.
__________________
And no one was ill, and everyone was pleased, except those who had to mow the grass. |
09-19-2003, 12:33 PM | #3 | |
Regal Dwarven Shade
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold
Posts: 3,591
|
I've often thought Aragorn should have kept the Dead around too, so perhaps I should leave it to the erudite wights who are less expediency driven than myself to answer, but I have one observation.
Quote:
[ September 19, 2003: Message edited by: Kuruharan ]
__________________
...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no... |
|
09-19-2003, 12:53 PM | #4 |
Wight
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Laurelindorenan
Posts: 225
|
Kuruharan, you are right. But Im thinking more about the possibility that by the time Frodo claims the One Ring in Mount Doom, Sauron's forces are being overrun by Aragorn and all the armies at the Morannon...
Which event deserves more attention? Your forces being destroyed in the Black Gate... or the hobbit in your mountain?
__________________
"In place of a Dark Lord you will have a Queen! Not dark but beatiful and terrible as the Dawn! Treacherous as the sea! Stronger than the foundations of the Earth! All shall love me and despair!" --- Galadriel when tempted by the One Ring. |
09-19-2003, 01:12 PM | #5 | |
Wight
|
I am the Queen of What If's in LotR but this one never occured to me. I don't think it was a mistake per se but more of a well thought out decision. There is more that could go wrong with the plan to bring the dead to Mordor. And Aragorn must have felt that his duty was to Gondor first or something of the like.
Quote:
[ September 19, 2003: Message edited by: Cinderella ]
__________________
These violent delights have violent ends... "Live fast, die young, and have a beautiful looking corpse." -J. Dean |
|
09-19-2003, 01:22 PM | #6 |
Regal Dwarven Shade
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold
Posts: 3,591
|
The hobbit in your mountain. The hobbit can't resist you. All you have to do is take the Ring back from him and all your problems will be solved.
__________________
...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no... |
09-19-2003, 01:22 PM | #7 |
Shade of Carn Dûm
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Up a tree somewhere in Caras Galadhon...or England
Posts: 364
|
Too true, person with the purple horse (I'm sorry, I can't remember your name!).
But I had always thought that the Dead conquered by scaring away all the people. Or was I wrong? Because if so, Sauron's people would be scattered, not destroyed, and if Frodo failed a little more utterly than he did in the books (ie no one challenged Frodo's taking of the Ring), and Sauron took it off Frodo, as no doubt he would, these Orcs etc would easily be reunited, methinks. Oooh long sentence...oops.
__________________
'"Forweg can lead you no longer; for he is dead...I slew him...I will govern this fellowship now, or leave it." "As it was when he joined us, so it is again. He kills to make room."' |
09-19-2003, 02:18 PM | #8 |
Hungry Ghoul
Join Date: Jun 2000
Posts: 1,719
|
As usually, the answer can be found in the books. In this case, we have the - as I will show - clearly wrong assumption that Aragorn could have taken the army of the Dead further than the Pelennor. However, LotR V,2 disproves this:
“Then Aragorn said: ‘The hour is come at last. Now I go to Pelargir upon Anduin, and ye shall come after me. And when all this land is clean of the servants of Sauron, I will hold the oath fulfilled, and ye shall have peace and depart for ever.” If Aragorn made a mistake at all, it would have been to set the condition for the fulfillment of the oath like he did, and not extend it. Given that we should assume Aragorn’s knowledge to be greater than ours, we can conclude that the original oath the Dead had broken did in turn NOT extend beyond ‘this land’. Added to this would be the fact that the Dead Men were hardly an apt army, let alone retinue for a King unless in most dire need: “But defenders and foes alike gave up the battle and fled when we came, crying out that the King of the Dead was upon them. Only Angbor, Lord of Lamedon, had the heart to abide us;” (LotR V,9). |
09-19-2003, 04:46 PM | #9 |
Deathless Sun
|
Also, the Dead once served Sauron himself. That was the reason that Isildur cursed them in the first place. Even though Aragorn has great strength of will, and can even be said to be a match for Sauron (he did wrest back the Palantir of Orthanc), would he be able to ensure the loyalty of the army of the Dead? Shades, fear, wraiths, and etc. are under Sauron's dominion, and the Big S. definitely has more experience than Aragorn in commanding armies, ensuring their loyalty (even through fear), etc. I'm not sure that the Dead would stay beside Aragorn if they were confronted with Sauron's forces.
__________________
But Melkor also was there, and he came to the house of Fëanor, and there he slew Finwë King of the Noldor before his doors, and spilled the first blood in the Blessed Realm; for Finwë alone had not fled from the horror of the Dark. |
09-19-2003, 05:45 PM | #10 | |
Corpus Cacophonous
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: A green and pleasant land
Posts: 8,390
|
As usual, the answer can be found in Sharkû's post. [img]smilies/wink.gif[/img]
But, even assuming that the original oath did extend beyond the lands of Gondor, I am not at all sure that the Army of the Dead would have been an effective force against the host of Sauron. As Kuruharan stated: Quote:
[ September 19, 2003: Message edited by: The Saucepan Man ]
__________________
Do you mind? I'm busy doing the fishstick. It's a very delicate state of mind! |
|
09-19-2003, 06:50 PM | #11 |
Wight
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Laurelindorenan
Posts: 225
|
But effective or not, the army of the Dead would have proved a very needed support when the confrontation at the Morannon. Fear was indeed their biggest weapon, but not the only one.
Besides, Sauron would not control the army. Even though Gorthaur does indeed control a vast army of creepy creatures, and even though he controls the Nazgul and the Silent Watchers, it doesnt mean that he can control every phantom he knew about... If he did, then the army of the Dead would not have supported Aragorn in the Pelennor, and certainly they would not have been imprisioned by the "mere" curse of a human king... Besides, it was an army. An enormous force that proved to be the decisive force when the Pelennor... being dead, they cant be destroyed by the Dark Lord's army... And fighting against orcs, men and trolls without being destroyed would have proved victory for Aragorn and Co.
__________________
"In place of a Dark Lord you will have a Queen! Not dark but beatiful and terrible as the Dawn! Treacherous as the sea! Stronger than the foundations of the Earth! All shall love me and despair!" --- Galadriel when tempted by the One Ring. |
09-19-2003, 06:53 PM | #12 |
Wight
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Laurelindorenan
Posts: 225
|
And the Army of the Dead fulfilled their oath because they wanted to rid themselves of the curse and rest in peace...
They would not committ the same mistake twice and condemn themselves to another zillion years cursed to live as undead... Theyre dead, not stupid... they would not commit the same mistake twice...
__________________
"In place of a Dark Lord you will have a Queen! Not dark but beatiful and terrible as the Dawn! Treacherous as the sea! Stronger than the foundations of the Earth! All shall love me and despair!" --- Galadriel when tempted by the One Ring. |
09-20-2003, 09:08 AM | #13 | |||
Regal Dwarven Shade
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold
Posts: 3,591
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no... |
|||
09-20-2003, 04:47 PM | #14 |
Deathless Sun
|
I don't think Baldor died of fear, rather, he probably died of something more practical and realistic, hunger and thirst. He had trapped himself inside the Paths (and I'm assuming that his was the skeleton that Aragorn & Co. found in the Paths) and since dead men don't need food or drink, there was none in there. Baldor slowly starved to death, and eventually tried to hack his way out, breaking his sword (which Aragorn & Co. also found).
__________________
But Melkor also was there, and he came to the house of Fëanor, and there he slew Finwë King of the Noldor before his doors, and spilled the first blood in the Blessed Realm; for Finwë alone had not fled from the horror of the Dark. |
09-21-2003, 07:09 AM | #15 |
Regal Dwarven Shade
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold
Posts: 3,591
|
You are certainly entitled to your opinion, there is not any way to prove it one way or the other. I just don't think that the "starved to death" theory quite squares with the effect that the Dead had on everybody else (except Aragorn and company).
__________________
...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no... |
09-21-2003, 01:34 PM | #16 |
Deathless Sun
|
You've got a point there. Baldor could have also gone mad with fear, and tried to hack his way out of the place, also effectively shattering his sword.
__________________
But Melkor also was there, and he came to the house of Fëanor, and there he slew Finwë King of the Noldor before his doors, and spilled the first blood in the Blessed Realm; for Finwë alone had not fled from the horror of the Dark. |
09-21-2003, 02:08 PM | #17 |
Dread Horseman
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Behind you!
Posts: 2,743
|
A point of clarification is in order: the Oathbreakers never came to the Pelennor. Aragorn released them after they frightened off the defenders at Pelargir. It is probably no stretch to assume that the dead would make lousy crewmen for a fleet, and in any case, would make it impossible to bring living allies along, as that Shadow Army had the pesky tactical drawback of scaring the wits out of friend and foe alike.
|
09-22-2003, 07:31 AM | #18 | |
Regal Dwarven Shade
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold
Posts: 3,591
|
Quote:
__________________
...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no... |
|
09-22-2003, 09:11 AM | #19 |
Dread Horseman
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Behind you!
Posts: 2,743
|
The old "scatter all formations to the four winds" tactic, eh?
As history has shown, grabbing a piece of ground and holding it are two different things (especially if all your friendly forces are gibbering and drooling with fear in the deepest cave they could find to hide in). Beyond mere tactics, though, there's little strategic value to be gained in such a dubious 'victory'. Hitching your cart to an Army of the Dead just doesn't pay. There's no future in it. |
09-22-2003, 10:44 AM | #20 | |
Shade of Carn Dûm
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Up a tree somewhere in Caras Galadhon...or England
Posts: 364
|
Yeah, especially if all they can do is scare the wits out of people.
Quote:
__________________
'"Forweg can lead you no longer; for he is dead...I slew him...I will govern this fellowship now, or leave it." "As it was when he joined us, so it is again. He kills to make room."' |
|
09-22-2003, 06:48 PM | #21 |
Deathless Sun
|
I think that Aragorn wanted to fight his battles on his own terms, mainly to prove to himself and to the world that he was a worthy Heir of Isildur, and that he could reunite the Kingdoms of Arnor and Gondor, with his own strength and will-power, on his own terms. If he had used the Army of the Dead at the Pelennor Fields, folk would have said that it was due to their strength that Aragorn won, not due to his own strength. A King who comes to power thanks to the strength of others is no King at all, and Aragorn realized that. He knew that he could have to fight for his kingship (and eventuallly with it the hand of Arwen) by himself. (by himself being a relative term, since Legolas, Gimli, & Co. were with him).
__________________
But Melkor also was there, and he came to the house of Fëanor, and there he slew Finwë King of the Noldor before his doors, and spilled the first blood in the Blessed Realm; for Finwë alone had not fled from the horror of the Dark. |
09-22-2003, 07:17 PM | #22 | |||||
Corpus Cacophonous
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: A green and pleasant land
Posts: 8,390
|
Quote:
The fact that the Oathbreakers were not present at the Pelennor is interesting in light of the condition which Aragorn set on their service (as posted previously by Sharkû): Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Aragorn was certainly wise not to bring the Army of the Dead to the Pelennor. Imagine the fear and confusion that this would have caused amongst the Men of Rohan and Gondor, regardless of its effect on their enemies. To say that it would not be good for morale would be a considerable understatement. And I would maintain that they would not be an effective force against those amongst Sauron's army who came from the Land of Shadow and who were themselves led by those masters of the use of fear as a weapon, the Nazgul.
__________________
Do you mind? I'm busy doing the fishstick. It's a very delicate state of mind! |
|||||
09-24-2003, 07:11 AM | #23 | |
Regal Dwarven Shade
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold
Posts: 3,591
|
Quote:
The problems would probably be social rather than military. [ September 24, 2003: Message edited by: Kuruharan ]
__________________
...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no... |
|
09-24-2003, 09:59 AM | #24 | |
Dread Horseman
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Behind you!
Posts: 2,743
|
As Clausewitz observed, “The War of a community--of whole Nations, and particularly of civilised Nations--always starts from a political condition, and is called forth by a political motive. It is, therefore, a political act. [...] If we reflect that War has its root in a political object, then naturally this original motive which called it into existence should also continue the first and highest consideration in its conduct.”
Aragorn’s political objective, of course, was to claim the throne of Gondor. It would have been a grievous error both politically and strategically for Aragorn to press on from Pelargir with the Shadow Army (assuming he even could). He would forge a reputation as the “King of the Dead” (RotK, V, 2) and frighten and alienate friendly forces (not to mention the subjects he aspired to rule) instead of cementing key political alliances at the Pelennor and beyond as he did. Quote:
|
|
09-24-2003, 12:11 PM | #25 | |
Shade of Carn Dûm
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Up a tree somewhere in Caras Galadhon...or England
Posts: 364
|
Quote:
But I still am not convinced that were this to work it would be constructive- for the simple reason that it would scatter the allies too (as has been said many a time...so what on earth am I talking about??? [img]smilies/frown.gif[/img] )
__________________
'"Forweg can lead you no longer; for he is dead...I slew him...I will govern this fellowship now, or leave it." "As it was when he joined us, so it is again. He kills to make room."' |
|
09-24-2003, 05:38 PM | #26 |
A Northern Soul
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Valinor
Posts: 1,847
|
The remaining 8 Nazgul (at least) would not be scared of the Dead.
"Do you not know Death when you see it?" Also, I can't remember a quote, but it seems to me (if even unpspoken) the Dead were only held to redeeming themselves with one stand taken under their king. I don't think there was any reason (or possibility) of the Dead going on beyond their oath's fulfillment - they had waited a long time for redemption. After redemption, it seems certain they wouldn't have been able to continue with Aragorn even if they desired to. On their effectiveness, I'm very sceptical about the "scare factor." The orcs had been subject to Nazgul command (and some most likely had direct contact with Sauron or at least saw him) - the Nazgul and Sauron are quite terrifying on their own, something the orcs had to adjust to. Sharku also pointed out (in an earlier conversation between he and I) that the Dead's scariness was mainly effective with men because they are dead men anyway...even the orcs of Saruman or the Misty Mountains probably would not have been as susceptible to fear of the Dead. [ September 24, 2003: Message edited by: Legolas ]
__________________
...take counsel with thyself, and remember who and what thou art. |
09-24-2003, 10:30 PM | #27 |
Newly Deceased
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 10
|
Sauron was called "the Necromancer" in The Hobbit. That suggests that he has some control over at least some dead creatures, or uses death to perform spells. That suggests that while the Dead obviously have great effect on the men who serve Sauron, they may not have such an effect on the big guy himself.
|
09-25-2003, 08:56 AM | #28 | ||
Dread Horseman
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Behind you!
Posts: 2,743
|
Good points Lego. Here's some more backup:
Quote:
In one version of Gimli and Legolas’s account of the events at Pelargir, Gimli claims, “...the Shadow Host halted and wavered, unwilling at the last, as it seemed, to make war on Sauron.” This was softened in the final text, where the Shadow Host “hung back at the last” without any explanation for their reluctance. It’s reasonable to conclude that the Dead were bitter about having been cursed for centuries, and in any case they were cursed in the first place because they were faithless allies. Quote:
P.S. - Sauce, I forgot to congratulate you on the "fudging" of your earlier post. Drafted with the canniness of a true loyer! [ September 25, 2003: Message edited by: Mister Underhill ] |
||
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|