Who would be the rightul king in aman? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

elbenprincess · 06-23-2010, 12:29 PM

I mean the King of the noldor, we know that at the time when the noldor left aman finarfin became the king, but did that last until the third age? We know that finwe and feanor wouldn´t return from mandos, but what about fingolfin or turgon? Would they have the right to claim the title or wouldn´t they even be released from mandos, because of the curse? We know finrod was released, why should there be a differnet case for fingolfin? I beliefe he didn´t participated in the kingslaying too and he is still the older brother of finarfin.

06-23-2010, 12:29 PM	#1
elbenprincess Haunting Spirit Join Date: May 2010 Posts: 69	Who would be the rightul king in aman? I mean the King of the noldor, we know that at the time when the noldor left aman finarfin became the king, but did that last until the third age? We know that finwe and feanor wouldn´t return from mandos, but what about fingolfin or turgon? Would they have the right to claim the title or wouldn´t they even be released from mandos, because of the curse? We know finrod was released, why should there be a differnet case for fingolfin? I beliefe he didn´t participated in the kingslaying too and he is still the older brother of finarfin.