sauron winning? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Joseph · 02-01-2010, 02:19 AM

I have a question to ask would anyone be able to answer it?
My question is if Frodo had not been able to destroy the ring and sauron had got it back he would have been able to destroy Gondor and taken over middle earth but then what?
Could he have been destroyed another way by say Gandalf or is it possible that the Valar would come back and cast him into the void as they did with Melkor
Also what would have happened if Melkor had been good and Manwe evil. Would it have been the same as in the silmarillion or much much worse?

any ideas?
Thanks
Joseph

02-01-2010, 02:19 AM	#1
Joseph Newly Deceased Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: North Wales (United Kingdom) Posts: 8	sauron winning? I have a question to ask would anyone be able to answer it? My question is if Frodo had not been able to destroy the ring and sauron had got it back he would have been able to destroy Gondor and taken over middle earth but then what? Could he have been destroyed another way by say Gandalf or is it possible that the Valar would come back and cast him into the void as they did with Melkor Also what would have happened if Melkor had been good and Manwe evil. Would it have been the same as in the silmarillion or much much worse? any ideas? Thanks Joseph