Visit The *EVEN NEWER* Barrow-Downs Photo Page |
09-13-2009, 06:01 PM | #1 |
Wight
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Barad-Dur
Posts: 196
|
Inconsistencies
I'm sure fellow Tolkien enthusiasts can highlight inconsistencies in the books. Here's a few for starters : -
- At the Hornburg Gimli says he had "hewed naught but wood since Moria" after killing 2 orcs. But surely he had killed orcs at Parth Galen ? - Gandalf released Shadowfax in Eriador two months before the Company left Rivendell, but Eomer told Aragorn that the horse had returned to Rohan only 7 days before they met in the Wold. - Denethor and Saruman both encountered Sauron using their respective Palantir. Yet Denethor was not dominated and Saruman was. Surely it should have been the other way round ? - What was the point of Eowyn dressing up as Dernhelm ? Surely the sight of a hobbit sitting on her horse with her would have given her away anyway ? Same goes for the scene in the film before the Riders charge at the Pelennor. - Why didn't the Ents intercept Mauhur and his "lads" skulking in Fangorn ? - If time was of the essence, why did the Company take so long before setting off from Rivendell and why did they hang about for so long in Lorien ? - Why did Aragorn not tell the rest of the Company that Gollum was following them through Moria ? "You know about our little footpad" . - If Gildor and his company could see off the Black Riders, wouldn't it have made more sense for Gildor to provide an escort for Frodo to get him safely to Rivendell ? - When Boromir's horse bolted at Tharbad and returned to Rohan, surely Edoras would have told Minas Tirith, who in turn would have organised some kind of search party ? - If Gwaihir could fly to Mount Doom in a matter of minutes, why not just give him the Ring and ask him to fly down there and drop it in the volcano ? |
|
|