Visit The *EVEN NEWER* Barrow-Downs Photo Page |
06-27-2009, 12:33 PM | #1 | |
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
|
Turin=Achilles?
In reading the Iliad (well, okay, listening to a cd lecture by Elizabeth
Vandiver) I noticed an increasingly interesting parallel between Achilles and Turin. Given Tolkien's schooling in Greek language and history, I wonder how much was conscious and are there other classical parallels mto Middle-earth personages (I tend to view the valar as more archangels then Greek/Roman gods, but still...). Granted, Tolkien says the chief inspiration was the Kullervo, there seem to be interesting Achilles similarities. Consider Achilles/Turin: 1) He's the greatest warrior in archaic Greek mythology 2) They both have tempers and make rash decisions and then stubbornly hold to them- Turin won't go back to Menegroth and Achilles won't rejoin battle even though Agamemnon handsomely apologizes for swiping Achilles concubine 3) Both die young, fighting as warriors and achieve great things for their sides---Achilles kills Hector, Turin kills Glaurung 4) They both have cranky superiors who tick them off (Agamemnon and Thingol) 5) Both have a hand in their best friend's deaths (Achilles by letting Petroclos use his armor) 6) Both unjustly kill people due to their rash temper (Achilles the young son of Priam-Lykaon, and Turin Brandir). The commentary by professor Vandiver on Achilles could be easily transposed to Turin: Quote:
in effect for their milieus (sp.?) choosing cowardice, eschew prowess in battle: Achilles by choosing a quiet life without lasting fame and Turin by abandoning his (granted frequently misguided) defending those he holds dear, his family and former home and Finduilas and Menegroth. Btw, both Agamemnon and Thingol seek to repair their relationships with their prickly warriors and their overtures are both rebuffed. What do you think? Any other possible Middle-earth classical parallels?
__________________
The poster formerly known as Tuor of Gondolin. Walking To Rivendell and beyond 12,555 miles passed Nt./Day 5: Pass the beacon on Nardol, the 'Fire Hill.' |
|
|
|