All Serious Tolkien Fans Read - The Lord of the Rings Favorite Character Study - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Peregrin Took · 11-30-2008, 01:36 PM

Greetings to all! Long time no see.

Today my good Tolkien friends, I am embarking on an adventure. I have expressed before here on the Barrow-Downs my interest in knowing people's favorite character(s) in Tolkien's world - in specific the characters in The Lord of the Rings. Meaning, why people choose their favorite character and what draws them to a certain identity.

I have decided to conduct a study on this exact question -

Who is your favorite character in The Lord of the Rings, and why?

Yet I'm not looking to start just another favorites thread - I'm not looking to briefly discuss in a post why you are drawn to a certain character. This is to be a grand project of online Tolkien fans, and I have set up two external links for the study. This study will be conducted over a long range of time, with no specific stop date (as of now). Here is what I expect from this study as well as what I am aiming to do:

Being of a "MySpace" era, I have decided to create the official page of my study through a MySpace page. Here is the link -

The Lord of the Rings Favorite Character Study

If you would like to read the rest of what I am going to say, feel free to visit the official page. If not, read on, for I will take exactly what is written on my MySpace page and post it here.

The first step of this study is a simple poll. I have created, through "PollDaddy.com" (quite the funny name, I know, but they have a neat system!) a poll listing 33 characters in The Lord of the Rings. This part is simple - Who Is Your Favorite Character? - vote for whoever your favorite character is.

The next step is what I call the "post-vote" process - this is where the heart of this study truly lies. For every serious fan of Tolkien who would like to get involved, I am requesting that after you cast your vote you send me a 3 page minimum essay describing why the character you picked is your favorite. You must cite examples from the text of LotR and, if you see fit, other Tolkien works in explaining your choice. These submissions should be typed in a Microsoft Word document with a font-size of 12. They must be double-spaced and sent to my e-mail deedsofpippin@yahoo.com as an attachment. Your name, e-mail address, and location (not your exact address) should be typed at the top of your submission as well as in your e-mail. I'm sorry about the strict regulations, but like I stated prior - serious Tolkien fans only.

Your writing should be clear and coherent, with proper spelling and punctuation. I apologize to non-English speaking fans, but only submissions in English are accepted.

My goal - When all is said and done, I will compile the best essays together in one volume and, having a better understanding of why different people choose different characters as their favorite, show them to the world. I would like to have at least one essay for each character that received a vote. If your favorite character happens to be a popular one - try your hardest to develop the best essay to ensure that your words make the cut. For example, if I receive fifty essays on why Frodo is your favorite character, five to ten at the most on Frodo will be included in the final work.

Have fun with this. Really dive into yourself and explain why you love the character that you have chosen. Do not hold back. You might discover a lot about yourself just by explaining why you enjoy a certain character! Let's show the world why the power of Tolkien is so great - why his world and his characters touch us so deeply and affect our daily lives.

I am sure Tolkien fans everywhere will find the results very interesting when all is said and done.

If you are interested in this study, please participate! I am going to be going all over the web to various Tolkien forums and sharing the same thing that I have shared with you. Admins, If the study is received with open arms, perhaps you can even help me promote this study?

I feel like this will create a chance for all those who want to express how much they love Tolkien to really get heard.

Thank you all so much for reading my extremely long post and I really hope you choose to take part of my study. If you are interested in this...start writing!

Sincerely,
Matthew

11-30-2008, 01:36 PM	#1
Peregrin Took Animated Skeleton Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: The Shire Posts: 38	All Serious Tolkien Fans Read - The Lord of the Rings Favorite Character Study Greetings to all! Long time no see. Today my good Tolkien friends, I am embarking on an adventure. I have expressed before here on the Barrow-Downs my interest in knowing people's favorite character(s) in Tolkien's world - in specific the characters in The Lord of the Rings. Meaning, why people choose their favorite character and what draws them to a certain identity. I have decided to conduct a study on this exact question - Who is your favorite character in The Lord of the Rings, and why? Yet I'm not looking to start just another favorites thread - I'm not looking to briefly discuss in a post why you are drawn to a certain character. This is to be a grand project of online Tolkien fans, and I have set up two external links for the study. This study will be conducted over a long range of time, with no specific stop date (as of now). Here is what I expect from this study as well as what I am aiming to do: Being of a "MySpace" era, I have decided to create the official page of my study through a MySpace page. Here is the link - The Lord of the Rings Favorite Character Study If you would like to read the rest of what I am going to say, feel free to visit the official page. If not, read on, for I will take exactly what is written on my MySpace page and post it here. The first step of this study is a simple poll. I have created, through "PollDaddy.com" (quite the funny name, I know, but they have a neat system!) a poll listing 33 characters in The Lord of the Rings. This part is simple - Who Is Your Favorite Character? - vote for whoever your favorite character is. The next step is what I call the "post-vote" process - this is where the heart of this study truly lies. For every serious fan of Tolkien who would like to get involved, I am requesting that after you cast your vote you send me a 3 page minimum essay describing why the character you picked is your favorite. You must cite examples from the text of LotR and, if you see fit, other Tolkien works in explaining your choice. These submissions should be typed in a Microsoft Word document with a font-size of 12. They must be double-spaced and sent to my e-mail deedsofpippin@yahoo.com as an attachment. Your name, e-mail address, and location (not your exact address) should be typed at the top of your submission as well as in your e-mail. I'm sorry about the strict regulations, but like I stated prior - serious Tolkien fans only. Your writing should be clear and coherent, with proper spelling and punctuation. I apologize to non-English speaking fans, but only submissions in English are accepted. My goal - When all is said and done, I will compile the best essays together in one volume and, having a better understanding of why different people choose different characters as their favorite, show them to the world. I would like to have at least one essay for each character that received a vote. If your favorite character happens to be a popular one - try your hardest to develop the best essay to ensure that your words make the cut. For example, if I receive fifty essays on why Frodo is your favorite character, five to ten at the most on Frodo will be included in the final work. Have fun with this. Really dive into yourself and explain why you love the character that you have chosen. Do not hold back. You might discover a lot about yourself just by explaining why you enjoy a certain character! Let's show the world why the power of Tolkien is so great - why his world and his characters touch us so deeply and affect our daily lives. I am sure Tolkien fans everywhere will find the results very interesting when all is said and done. If you are interested in this study, please participate! I am going to be going all over the web to various Tolkien forums and sharing the same thing that I have shared with you. Admins, If the study is received with open arms, perhaps you can even help me promote this study? I feel like this will create a chance for all those who want to express how much they love Tolkien to really get heard. Thank you all so much for reading my extremely long post and I really hope you choose to take part of my study. If you are interested in this...start writing! Sincerely, Matthew __________________ "I am not a fighter. But it would be politer in any case for the challenger to say who he is." Formerly MatthewM, joined Jun 2006.