Inquiries - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Kuruharan · 01-01-2003, 12:37 PM

1) Did PJ have a cameo in this movie? I remember that he was in Fellowship, but I don't remember seeing him in TTT.<P>2) Was the Elf in the Dead Marshes supposed to be somebody important? I'm asking because 1) he was in one piece and 2) he had dark hair if I remember correctly (a rather rare thing for an Elf in Jackson's Middle-earth).<P>3) I assume that the extended version of the TTT will show how in the process of trundling across Rohan the homogenous band of Saruman's Uruk-hai suddenly turned in to the heterogeneous horde of various orcs. When I saw the scene with the orcs arguing I did a double take because all of a sudden there were a bunch of smaller orcs there that just mysteriously appeared out of nowhere. Or was this something that I was not supposed to notice?<P>4) Why did Aragorn advise Theoden to send for help to Gondor? Wasn't he the one who had just ridden in all fainting and bleeding to announce "There's a whole bunch of orcs coming, they'll be here TONIGHT, and we're all gonna die!!!!!" How did he expect poor under-attack Gondor to send help when they were several days ride away, assuming they could even send help immediately. Or is this just a plot hole?

01-01-2003, 12:37 PM	#1
Kuruharan Regal Dwarven Shade Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: A Remote Dwarven Hold Posts: 3,593	Inquiries 1) Did PJ have a cameo in this movie? I remember that he was in Fellowship, but I don't remember seeing him in TTT.<P>2) Was the Elf in the Dead Marshes supposed to be somebody important? I'm asking because 1) he was in one piece and 2) he had dark hair if I remember correctly (a rather rare thing for an Elf in Jackson's Middle-earth).<P>3) I assume that the extended version of the TTT will show how in the process of trundling across Rohan the homogenous band of Saruman's Uruk-hai suddenly turned in to the heterogeneous horde of various orcs. When I saw the scene with the orcs arguing I did a double take because all of a sudden there were a bunch of smaller orcs there that just mysteriously appeared out of nowhere. Or was this something that I was not supposed to notice?<P>4) Why did Aragorn advise Theoden to send for help to Gondor? Wasn't he the one who had just ridden in all fainting and bleeding to announce "There's a whole bunch of orcs coming, they'll be here TONIGHT, and we're all gonna die!!!!!" How did he expect poor under-attack Gondor to send help when they were several days ride away, assuming they could even send help immediately. Or is this just a plot hole? __________________ ...finding a path that cannot be found, walking a road that cannot be seen, climbing a ladder that was never placed, or reading a paragraph that has no...