What if... - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Blue Elf · 01-25-2003, 01:56 PM

This is where you discuss "what if's" and the results (funny what if's, but nothing insane) such as, "What if Bilbo gave Frodo a fake Ring because he could not give up his own" or "What if Frodo dropped the Ring along the way" (hey, his chain did break on the Caradras...).

Oh, I have check the search, and there didn't seem to be a what if... except for "What if there was a different ringbearer" which is a different topic altogether.

So, let's start off with...

What if ...Gandalf had truly died in Moria?

(Note: does this topic belong more in the books section? I wasn't sure where it should go)

So, if Gandalf had died in Moria, what do you think might have happened? Well, for one, Saruman wouldn't be defeated, right? So then we have Saruman in the picture...but he would also be trapped by a storm of ents, so would it make a difference?

What do you think?

01-25-2003, 01:56 PM	#1
Blue Elf Wight Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Gollum's cave Posts: 124	What if... This is where you discuss "what if's" and the results (funny what if's, but nothing insane) such as, "What if Bilbo gave Frodo a fake Ring because he could not give up his own" or "What if Frodo dropped the Ring along the way" (hey, his chain did break on the Caradras...). Oh, I have check the search, and there didn't seem to be a what if... except for "What if there was a different ringbearer" which is a different topic altogether. So, let's start off with... What if ...Gandalf had truly died in Moria? (Note: does this topic belong more in the books section? I wasn't sure where it should go) So, if Gandalf had died in Moria, what do you think might have happened? Well, for one, Saruman wouldn't be defeated, right? So then we have Saruman in the picture...but he would also be trapped by a storm of ents, so would it make a difference? What do you think? __________________ ...and when I conquer the world, you can be in charge of my ray gun!