This might sound like a weird thought... - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

charly · 10-22-2002, 09:52 AM

...but it came to me a while a go, and I kept on wondering. So, here´s the thing:
it´s after the war of the ring. Aragorn is king and lives happpily ever after... but there´s a problem. A big one. It turns out Arwen can not have children. Every time it seems she´s pregnant she looses the baby very early. Aragorn has to decide. If he doesn´t have a son, Elendil´s line will dissapear from ME forever, he will either have to adopt an heir, or his name will be forgotten. Or he abadoms (sp?) Arwen and marries for the second time. A young ,fertile princess, maybe Eomer´s daughter or something.DO YOU THINK HE COULD HAVE DONE IT???? I just don´t know what to think.

There´s to much evidence in history that men choose divorces instead of their loves. Most of all, Napoleon and Josephine. I consider it the greatest lovestory in history. The two were linked together, loved each other dearly but when it tourned out Josephine was infertile ,he divorced her. He never stopped loving her, but he divorced her in favour of an heir.

So what would have happend with Aragorn and Arwen?? This question might sound cruel and unbeliveable, but imagine it... I wonder what you think.

10-22-2002, 09:52 AM	#1
charly Haunting Spirit Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: middle earth, dork Posts: 84	This might sound like a weird thought... ...but it came to me a while a go, and I kept on wondering. So, here´s the thing: it´s after the war of the ring. Aragorn is king and lives happpily ever after... but there´s a problem. A big one. It turns out Arwen can not have children. Every time it seems she´s pregnant she looses the baby very early. Aragorn has to decide. If he doesn´t have a son, Elendil´s line will dissapear from ME forever, he will either have to adopt an heir, or his name will be forgotten. Or he abadoms (sp?) Arwen and marries for the second time. A young ,fertile princess, maybe Eomer´s daughter or something.DO YOU THINK HE COULD HAVE DONE IT???? I just don´t know what to think. There´s to much evidence in history that men choose divorces instead of their loves. Most of all, Napoleon and Josephine. I consider it the greatest lovestory in history. The two were linked together, loved each other dearly but when it tourned out Josephine was infertile ,he divorced her. He never stopped loving her, but he divorced her in favour of an heir. So what would have happend with Aragorn and Arwen?? This question might sound cruel and unbeliveable, but imagine it... I wonder what you think. __________________ "Whom do you serve, scum?"

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Threaded Mode