Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Amanaduial the archer]

The three have been fairly silent and while Malkatoj has said it is because of his schooling, I can't recall if TGWBS or Amanduial had any excuses.

Not on this thread, no, but I did comment on that on the general Tol-in-Gaurhoth discussion thread: I am a student, and due to other extra-curricular activities (such as the Shostakovichfest concert and rehersals all day today, hence my only coming on just now), I have rather limited time to post. I'm doing my best

So the votes stand thus so far:

Nilpaurion Felagun - 4 (Farael, Alcarillo, Valier, Menel)
Naria - 1 (Lhuna)
TGWBS - 1 (Malkatoj)
Kuru - 1 (TGWBS)

Left to vote: 8 people (Nilpaurion, Rune, Naria, Amana, Kuruharan, Azaelia, Cailin, Gurthang).

Looks like 'The Carnivore' as he bills himself is making a comeback with four votes. However, I'm afraid I must stand with what my standing opinion throughout the game: I really do not consider Nilp to be a wolf. He's just too blatant - I honestly do not think there could be a double bluff that elaborate. Although it may annoy him, I am not a Nilp-basher. Gurthang and Kuru pointed out the interesting point (oh, vocabulary failure) that his death could answer some interesting questions - but I won't vote for him on this basis. However much it may annoy him, I stand by my earlier words: I refuse to vote for Nilp mainly because he told us to!

People I have consistently been suspicious of so far include Lhuna and Cailin. Now, my suspicions on Cailin are waning - she's just so damn rational! - but Lhuna...ah, Lhuna, Lhuna, Lhuna. Like Cailin said, she did display something of a change in attitude today - and she seems rather fixed on throwing all suspicions of her guilt onto Nilp, constantly 'warning' us about him - where he's one villager whose guilt I really doubt. I'm not sure: three quarters of an hour left, I'm not sure I'll vote quite yet, leave it for a wee while, but I've got my eye on you. Two people who I would really like to hear more from are Naria and Azaelia. Sneakily quiet, and I should like to see how Naria responds to all the suspicion raised around her - I must admit, a very good case is being made against her, and it is most convincing - she is currently in line with Lhuna for my vote today...