Making RPG proposals in Rohan (and the Shire)-- a tutorial

[Mithadan]

After discussion with the innkeepers, proposal reviewers, mods, etc., we think that a demonstration on how to submit a proposal for an RPG is in order. The intent of this thread is to not just review the form used to make such proposals but rather to provide insight into what the innkeepers, proposal reviewers and mods are looking for and how they make their decisions, recommendations and suggestions.

We have found a suitable volunteer (sacrificial lamb) to submit a proposal which initially will be extremely flawed by our standards. The end result of this exercise will be an example of an acceptable proposal (and a new RPG).

Only innkeepers, proposal reviewers and mods may post on this thread to comment on the proposal submitted. However, all are welcome to pose questions about our proposal process here.