Reputations

[Amanaduial the archer]

Hmm. The rep system can, it seem, be rather problematic when certain sun-lulled or sleepy Downers try to add to a reputation...and send off the wrong type of rep. Negative where positive was meant and vice-versa. It has happened to me once before (although the rep didn't carry any points: I was rather amused when I got such a positive comment beside a negative reputation ) and I, ah, I may have just done it to someone else...wrong button....*winces*

[Firefoot]

Well, I was perusing this thread a bit and I found some gems:

Fordim Hedgethistle has now reached "---has the fame of Frodo". Hmm...wonder if there could be any higher?

Does that mean there could be up to ten little green boxes?!

On a less humorous note:

I like giving positive rep, it feels good. It makes me feel happy inside.

Maybe we should all feel a little bit more like this.

[VanimaEdhel]

Now that I've been back for a few days, I've found that, unless I see this thread, giving someone a reputation upgrade (or downgrade) hardly ever crosses my mind. If they make a good post, I say in the thread, "Great post!" and if it's really spectacular, I'll send them a private message to continue the discussion. If it isn't such a great post, I've found that I just kind of ignore it and move on.

I think part of it is that I don't want to give an anonymous rep, but at the same time, I'm rather shy at the thought of giving a comment along with it. I never have anything witty to say, and I don't want to send a message just saying, "You are a splendiferous poster, I so much enjoy you", because, well, a message without a bit of sarcasm just isn't me. And so often, I don't know the person well enough to know how they'll take a little sarcasm.

Originally Posted by Amanaduial the Archer

The rep system can, it seem, be rather problematic when certain sun-lulled or sleepy Downers try to add to a reputation...and send off the wrong type of rep.

Aman, do we have to put a little special Aman Restriction System on your computer where it measures you fatigue and determines the best course of action? Or it could always flash a little message before actually sending it saying, "Are you sure you want to send a negative rep? That's a negative right? Just double check!"

Actually, an "Are You Sure?" message before you actually send it would be nice, now that I think about it.

[The Only Real Estel]

Hey, Vanima, is it my imagination or have you shot up three or four boxes in...nine days?

[wilwarin538]

I now have the fame of Frodo! Thanks to alatar and someone who not only didn't sign the rep but didn't even put a comment.

[VanimaEdhel]

Originally Posted by The Only Real Estel

Hey, Vanima, is it my imagination or have you shot up three or four boxes in...nine days?

*Looks* WOW! I did. I didn't notice that. I check the Reps in CP and saw a bunch more added, but I never really looked at how many boxes I had.

Well, I think that's a "Welcome Back" if I ever saw one. I've been a pretty busy little thing over in the "Books" section, especially in the "Tolkien a Religion?" - a debate I can get into.

[The Only Real Estel]

It had been a long time since I'd recieved any unsigned reps but now two of my last three have been unsigned. o_O Oh well, I think I have a pretty good idea of at least one of those, so it's not eating at me too badly...

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Who do you think it was, TOREstel?

[The Only Real Estel]

Hey! I had just decided on who I thought it was & told myself that I wasn't even going to think about it anymore & now you're trying to stir up my speculations again (& it's working)! Now I'll have to PM everyone in the entire forum & cross-examine them.

[Meneltarmacil]

I did one of those, Estel. I just accidentally hit "enter" before I had finished typing it.

And I suspect it was the one you have a pretty good idea of too.

[The Only Real Estel]

Ah, one down one to go. Your efforts are thwarted, Fea. Almost at least...

[Encaitare]

You know Werewolf has become a huge thing when people sign their reps with ++screenname (you know who you are).

[Son of Númenor]

Lalwende has just 'ascended' to the rank of gaffer-confounding tater-thief. Quite a step up from that dreadful spot on the mountain, imo.

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by Son of Númenor

Lalwende has just 'ascended' to the rank of gaffer-confounding tater-thief. Quite a step up from that dreadful spot on the mountain, imo.

That's great!

Congatulation Lalwende. The first to break into that category...though now you're all alone.

[Encaitare]

Congrats, Lal! Hah, glad to see a sense of humor remains in these titles.

[the guy who be short]

Heartfelt congratulation, Lal.

That is seriously hilarious! *chuckes to self*

[wilwarin538]

Congrats Lal! That is very cool. I can only dream of being at that rank some day.

[Lalwendë]

I got all confused for a few minutes there, I was thinking "but I aint stolen no taters since I was a lass, what are they saying about me?"

Ah, a title I can live up to at least, and it was getting a bit windy so high up on Taniquetil (or it could be something to do with all the beans they've been eating, actually).

[Meneltarmacil]

I wonder what the next level will be. The one about taters and gaffers just doesn't make a whole lot of sense compared to the direction the previous ones were taking.

[Formendacil]

Hmm... most interesting...

Is this (the tater-theft business) a sign that past a certain point, one's reputation title takes on a humourous, rather than serious, air?

If so, t'is a good trend, say I, and I eagerly await the time when we can acclaim the crowning of our first "Gandalf the Grey Uncloaked".

~Playfully yours...

Formendacil~

[Encaitare]

Is this (the tater-theft business) a sign that past a certain point, one's reputation title takes on a humourous, rather than serious, air?

I think it means that Eru himself was known for his sticky fingers when around the taters, back in the day before he matured a bit and decided to do something productive with his life.

[THE Ka]

Is this (the tater-theft business) a sign that past a certain point, one's reputation title takes on a humourous, rather than serious, air?

I think its a wonderful surprise. Mainly, because you would think that you would recieve an even more 'godly' title, but... SURPRISE! Taters! It brings you down to earth... A bit more.


~ Surprised! Ka

[Kath]

I love the title Lalwende, but now davem's got some serious catching up to do!

[Hookbill the Goomba]

That title made me laugh considerably. Mainly at the suggestion that stealing taters from confused Gaffers is a feat not even Manwe could achieve!

[Lhunardawen]

Originally Posted by Encaitare

You know Werewolf has become a huge thing when people sign their reps with ++screenname (you know who you are).

Living up to his suspicious nature, ain't he?

Well, well...we were all thinking something related to Manwë...and we find this?!

Congratulations indeed, Lalwendë. It must be lonely at the top.

[Ainaserkewen]

What a weird next level...you have to wonder what was running through the BW's mind when he wrote these...

Congrats Lalwendë.

[wilwarin538]

I think some of us are getting a little obsessed with the werewolf games. I'm starting to get reps signed ++(username).

I think Gandalf the Grey Uncloaked would be great.

[Meneltarmacil]

I think you should be allowed to put last-minute changes into your comments. I mean, I've forgotten to sign the last few I've posted, and once I remember, it's always too late to go back and change it...

[Orominuialwen]

You could always Pm the person and explain. I once accidentally sent a completely blank rep, so I just PMed the person I sent it to to tell them the reason for the rep and who it was that sent it.

By the way, thanks to whoever it was that sent me an unsigned (but positive and with a comment) rep today. It way very nice of you, whoever you are!

[Boromir88]

I think you should be allowed to put last-minute changes into your comments. I mean, I've forgotten to sign the last few I've posted, and once I remember, it's always too late to go back and change it...

I just did that maybe...3 hrs ago. Although I do think I only left the "B" of my name, because I accidently hit "enter" and didn't finish it. And I do forget who I gave it to now.

[THE Ka]

Originally Posted by wilwarin538

I think some of us are getting a little obsessed with the werewolf games. I'm starting to get reps signed ++(username).

I recieved one too. I thought the '++' meant something along the lines of: "Mess with this thread again, and you'll need double the medical attention!", which is a good call for them, since i'm poor and can only pay to be killed by Group Death. Or, thinking positively (afterwards, I always take the worst first, not because I need excitement, it's more along the lines of 'I might as well get this over with'.) I though it was something like: " Good post! You have just earned slightly payable quality medical benefits from the BarrowDowns' own Werewolf Games!"

But, it is interesting, and fads do come and go...

~ Confessions of a middle-aged realist Ka

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Formendacil

Hmm... most interesting...

Is this (the tater-theft business) a sign that past a certain point, one's reputation title takes on a humourous, rather than serious, air?
Formendacil~

I wonder if Lal has gone so far she has tipped over the edge and is actually now at the lowest level, the previously unplumbed depths? Since so many of us prefer the carrot to the stick and the worst I can ever remember anyone being was "acting a bit like Ted Sandyman" (I think BW did list them at some point?)... stealing spuds from senile old codgers is a bit mean....

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

stealing spuds from senile old codgers is a bit mean....

Yon gaffers are very defensive over their taters. They have very sharp dibber sticks that they wave at you in a threatening manner, shouting "get orf my land".

Have there been new 'rep thingies' written then? I hope so, because it will be funny looking out for new ones, and waiting to see how surreal they can get. Though I do recall that the number of boxes can't go over 11?

[Lhunardawen]

Add one more jewel to the eleven and anyone looking at the Member by Rep List would suffer serious eye defects.

Oh, the things the Chief Wight comes up with...

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Lalwendë

Yon gaffers are very defensive over their taters. They have very sharp dibber sticks that they wave at you in a threatening manner, shouting "get orf my land".

Dibbers are all very well but I found that the guys in the office were careful not to annoy me the day I bought extending tree loppers at lunchtime....

But I was guessing.. I don't actually know

[Hookbill the Goomba]

Though I do recall that the number of boxes can't go over 11?

Perhaps one day, when you get to a certain amount, you will go back to one box, but it will be gold instead of green!

[Durelin]

"Lalwendë wonders what happened to the reputation system"...and so do I!

[the guy who be short]

And davem has advanced to the point of tater-thieving!

I can't help but wonder if my prediction that BW would go insane has come true...

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

I've just noticed that an esteemed Barrowdowner has been given negative rep for a post in which she makes a completely valid and on-topic point. This particularly saddens me because earlier I was seriously considering giving negative rep for the first time ever on the Downs. I managed to restrain myself, though I'm not sure why I bothered.

Good posts are receiving negative rep and hundreds of nonsense posts (many of them submitted by the same Barrowdowner) are being ignored.

Sorry to interrupt the jamboree here. Lalwende and davem truly deserve such praise for being so awesome.

[mormegil]

I recently received a negative rep on a post in the "First Age Trivia" thread. The post basically said "you're correct and your turn" the comment on the negative rep wasn't signed but said "Random Bad Rep" I find this ridiculous. I know that the phantom said something about this earlier I know it wasn't him, so I just wanted to clarify this. Giving Random bad rep is not what the system is for.