On Lommy
#70 - Comes out as anti-tie, queries the wisdom of instructing the dead thread, and "smells Freud" in regards to
Agan (the start of the infamous slip-fest). Again, re-reading it, I may be naive but it seems like a pretty straightforward
Agan-esque joke to me.
#129 - Clarifies where she's coming from re:
Agan, and I can kind of see where she's coming from in that the joke itself can kind of be read in two different lights ('lynching' vs 'killing' and the derivative of 'we'). Weirdly enough, I get the impression that had
Agan reacted to the alternate reading ('lynching' vs 'killing'),
Lommy would have been okay with it? Except to me they seem relatively the same. Perhaps I'm just reading into it differently. Anyway,
Lommy uses this as the basis for suspecting
Agan due to reacting a bit too wolvishly (I think?) She also mentions always suspecting
Lottie on Day 1, although I don't think anything ever came of this. I agree with her statements about not wasting lynch opportunities. I also basically agree with everything she's said thus far about the dead thread -
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lommy
I disagree. We cannot control the Dead Thread. I've been thinking about this and what I would do if I died and had to vote on the dead thread. First off, I would be likely to start lazing because following two threads and general frustration at being dead, ugh. (I'm being honest here.) Being the good citizen I am, I'd still probably get as far as voting. Now, would I follow the instructions of the living? Possibly, unless we dead people had a better idea. How to convey that to the living? And - I'm emphasizing this again - whose instructions would I follow? Say, the phantom suggests a course of action for the dead thread. Six living people state they agree. Four state they disagree. The rest don't comment. Now, are the living to assume the dead then followed the instructions? How could they know? Or what if two living players had two different ideas for what the dead should do and there was no clear consensus? Whose idea would the dead follow then? And how would the living ever deduce whose idea the dead went with?
Seriously, unless we elect a living village spokesperson or something, there's no way of clearly communicating with the dead. The best we can do is probably use our knowledge of the personalities and the playing styles of the deceased and try to guess what those particular players would do, but that's a little risky. In short, we shouldn't make decisions based on how we can use the dead thread until we have found a way to do so, because it's possible we'll never find one.
|
#133 - More about the dead thread.
#139 -
Lommy makes a list of everyone. It's worth noting that the only person in her "The Bad" category besides
Agan is
Sally, for -
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lommy
in a manner that makes me think of sneaky Sallywolves of the past
|
However, in her "The Ugly" category there are a number of people who appear to also be under the radar, including
Gwath, McCaber, Boro, and
Kath. It's also worth noting that
Lommy adds
Agan's position on tying the lynch (she's pro-tie) to reasons to suspect her.
#145 - More about the dead thread and the plan to get information from it.
#157 -
Lommy really cements her suspicion of
Agan here, adding
Agan's defensiveness (which, again, I tend to agree with, whatever the reason) to her reasoning. Honestly, the more I read
Lommy's posts the more I see where she's coming from. It is possible an
Aganwolf was trying to handwave
Lommy's suspicion of her by painting her as silly. I can't really speak with certainty for why
Agan might have made a slip (if indeed it is one), but -
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lommy
If you were innocent, you wouldn't be half as annoyed by me remarking on your wolvish perspective, and I suspect you're just enjoying your wolfing in this game with a nice pack and even the tiniest prospect that your enjoyment might be cut short both makes you fight back and gets on your nerves because you dislike being "busted" on something so trivial, especially if you indeed intentionally chose to comment on morm's joke from that angle and I was accusing you on the wrong grounds.
|
is kinda plausible, I guess. (I admit my first reaction to rereading this is what I'd say if she talked to me like this - "How do you know what I would and would not do in a given situation? You're not me."
)
Given that we're so close to DL, I'm going to go ahead and post the first part of this. I haven't seen
Lommy really suspect anyone else, which was the main reason I came back to do this in the first place, but I do admit to being a bit more suspicion of
Agan now. I have to wonder if the main reason I want to think
Agan is innocent is that I'm an emotional player like she is.