Oops, I totally failed to notice
Form and
Kath had voted before my first post.
I came out of yesterDay thinking loads of
Agan's innocence for her attempt to save
Eombadil of the Yellow Boots (and wishing I'd had sense enough not to ruin it), let's see whether that holds. At the time of her vote, the tally was
Eomer 3 votes,
me and
Agan herself 1 each, with
Eomer,
me and
Kath still to vote. Both
Eomer and
Agan had been suspected by
Greenie and
Form.
Eomer thought
Agan innocent and was unlikely to vote her (unless forced to in self-defense), but if both
Kath and me had voted
Agan, she could still have ended up being tied with
Eomer and lynched by coin flip (assuming
Agan and
Kath aren't wolves together). Where
Kath's vote would go seemed pretty uncertain, and I had expressly said that I was still trying to figure
Agan out. In this situation,
Eomer was her natural ally - hence my paranoia before DL that one of them was manipulating the other (and possibly me and
Kath too) to sacrifice
Form and save themselves; and
Agan wouldn't have wanted to put him into a position where he might turn against her to save himself, with the danger of me and
Kath following suit.
The problem is, all this equally applies to an innocent
Agan. All that's conclusive is that if
Agan's a wolf,
Kath can't be and vice versa, for in this case
Agan could have counted on
Kath to save her in any case and would have had no reason not to simply vote
Eomer (except that saving an innocent would make her look good, but I think it's a little late in the game for that).