Ok Loslote, you're being pretty obvious. I just hope the village doesn't fall for it.
A thousand times more sure about Eomer, eh? That's only meaning one thing.
Clearly, I can see your game, though no-one else will -- unless you-know-who (and I ain't talking Voldemort) steps forward - not sure if that's wise yet though.
Nerwen's remark was interesting too. She said there's 3 baddies to 4 innocents. There's no way she doesn't realise that the cobbler could be gone already, unless she is the cobbler; but why would she reveal as the cobbler right now? She could be manipulating us to deduce that she is the cobbler, so we don't 'waste' a kill on her.
Worrying. What does everybod else think about that? Or have I misread it?
I note Loslote gives a

in response. Too daring?