The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Aganzir · 08-26-2010, 03:12 PM

Friends are doing stuff I'm not needed for, so I'm going to make a quick summary. I haven't reread the thread, so it's mostly just the general opinions & impressions I have on people.

GUILTY
sally. Reacted unnecessarily jumpily to my vote (come on, it was day 1 and I wasn't super suspicious of anybody, it's nothing personal), and some things she says about people in #58 rubbed me the wrong way. Or maybe it's not the things she says but the way she says them that feels off to me. She also jumped on wilwa's suggestion we don't lynch EW in his absence which was her biggest game-related contribution after voting.
skip. Not necessarily a wolf (I'm still kind of doubtful whether he would've cast the first vote for a fellow) but he feels somehow awfully off. I'm toying with the idea he's the cobbler.
Eomer. Weird. I don't seem to get his reasoning at all, and his Greenie vote looks opportunistic.

INNOCENT
Fea. She voted for EW, and EW voted for her. While it's totally possible it's a wolfish scheme (you can't really rule out anything when we're talking of Fea), I think survival is in the wolves' best interests. However, I'm not actually trusting her, either.
wilwa. If she had really wanted to save EW, why didn't she vote for Fea who had more votes? Generally she makes sense and has good points, and although I'm by no means convinced of her innocence, I'm willing to trust her for now. Besides I'm somewhat concerned about how she seems to be today's easy lynching candidate.
Greenie. Seems innocentish enough and I'm not too worried about her at the moment, although I'm fully aware of how capable she's fooling me. I will probably want to have a look at her at some point though.

EITHER
Nerwen. I don't really like her vote for wilwa (she seems like such an easy target after defending EW yesterday), but apart from that she hasn't given me a reason to be suspicious.
Lottie. Voted for EW which makes her look more innocent, but why didn't she choose Fea or someone else she had expressed suspicion of? Hmm actually now that I think of it, her giving Fea four cobbler checks and saying very soon afterwards that she wasn't going to vote for her might be interpreted as a hint from a wolf to the cobbler... Not sure about that though because I still think giving hints to the cobbler wouldn't be worth the risk.
Boro. He generally seems to make sense, and he voted for a wolf, but there was something forced-looking in his decision.
Pitch. Apart from a slightly bad feeling yesterDay, he's been escaping my attention so far. Will have to remedy that when I can.

I'm probably going to vote for someone either on the Guilty or Either list.

08-26-2010, 03:12 PM	#138
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	Summary time! Friends are doing stuff I'm not needed for, so I'm going to make a quick summary. I haven't reread the thread, so it's mostly just the general opinions & impressions I have on people. GUILTY sally. Reacted unnecessarily jumpily to my vote (come on, it was day 1 and I wasn't super suspicious of anybody, it's nothing personal), and some things she says about people in #58 rubbed me the wrong way. Or maybe it's not the things she says but the way she says them that feels off to me. She also jumped on wilwa's suggestion we don't lynch EW in his absence which was her biggest game-related contribution after voting. skip. Not necessarily a wolf (I'm still kind of doubtful whether he would've cast the first vote for a fellow) but he feels somehow awfully off. I'm toying with the idea he's the cobbler. Eomer. Weird. I don't seem to get his reasoning at all, and his Greenie vote looks opportunistic. INNOCENT Fea. She voted for EW, and EW voted for her. While it's totally possible it's a wolfish scheme (you can't really rule out anything when we're talking of Fea), I think survival is in the wolves' best interests. However, I'm not actually trusting her, either. wilwa. If she had really wanted to save EW, why didn't she vote for Fea who had more votes? Generally she makes sense and has good points, and although I'm by no means convinced of her innocence, I'm willing to trust her for now. Besides I'm somewhat concerned about how she seems to be today's easy lynching candidate. Greenie. Seems innocentish enough and I'm not too worried about her at the moment, although I'm fully aware of how capable she's fooling me. I will probably want to have a look at her at some point though. EITHER Nerwen. I don't really like her vote for wilwa (she seems like such an easy target after defending EW yesterday), but apart from that she hasn't given me a reason to be suspicious. Lottie. Voted for EW which makes her look more innocent, but why didn't she choose Fea or someone else she had expressed suspicion of? Hmm actually now that I think of it, her giving Fea four cobbler checks and saying very soon afterwards that she wasn't going to vote for her might be interpreted as a hint from a wolf to the cobbler... Not sure about that though because I still think giving hints to the cobbler wouldn't be worth the risk. Boro. He generally seems to make sense, and he voted for a wolf, but there was something forced-looking in his decision. Pitch. Apart from a slightly bad feeling yesterDay, he's been escaping my attention so far. Will have to remedy that when I can. I'm probably going to vote for someone either on the Guilty or Either list. __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle. Last edited by Aganzir; 08-26-2010 at 03:15 PM. Reason: xed since my last post - they actually needed my help (in seducing a Sheikh ;))