Okay, I'm thinking this out:
Sally could technically have been bluffing about being Athena. However, everyone's posted toDay, and no-one's made loud noises about lynching her, so I think I can take her to be a provisional known innocent.
Does this make her
necessarily right about
Shasta? Well, no, because Hephaestus might have simply missed Aphrodite's hint on Day One– i.e. the people who tried to save
BG had no ulterior motive.
Meanwhile, everyone seems to assume
phantom is Zeus. In that case, as Zeus has apparently turned cobbler, he presumably
doesn't really believe Shasta is Hades*. Does that make him
necessarily wrong about him? Again no, because Zeus doesn't know the identity of the other wolves.
And if
phantom is really, say, Hades to Foley's
Persephone, or vice versa, or anything like that, we're more-or-less done for anyway. I'm afraid that is a possibility, too– cf. all that about telling people not to look through his posts– was he afraid we'd find something?
*
Mira's ignoring this
(#1151) isn't exactly a point in her favour. (Foley likewise, but as I said, there's nothing we can do about that.)
EDIT:clarification.