Once again, to address this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Macalaure
This means that the actually interesting thing to talk about are the reactions to him. I see three possible wolfish responses. 1. Agreement, in an effort to lead the village astray side by side with an innocent Boro, 2. Plain disagreement, putting oneself on the majority's side anticipating the general disagreement or going along with it now that it's there, 3. Maintaining the discussion, so that the village wastes time talking about things that don't matter.
1: none
2: Nogrod, disagrees without a fuss, which actually doesn't look very suspicious; Pitch's comment might be suspicious.
3: Inziladun, starting with "Huh?" and continuing; Nerwen, first merely picking up what Roa and Inzil said, then going into attack now (which would look innocent if her tone wasn't so darn sinister); Morsul made himself comfortable on the fence.
|
When I said this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by me
Huh?  |
It was bedtime, and I really didn't get where
Boro was going with that line of thought. But then, to say I was 'maintaining the discussion', when all I'd said was this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by me
I see [Boro's] point now regarding Gifted survival strategy, and yes, that sort of thing has led to their being lynched. But I don't see any certain way of divining which we're looking at: a nervous Gifted, or a brash wolf. Do you have any ideas?
|
That's a reach,
Mac.
And it really does look to me as if you were leaving the door open to raise suspicion on anyone who responded to
Boro's comments.
I don't read much into
Roa's misnumbering the wolves. It wouldn't get her very far as a wolf, in my opinion, and I think she's quite savvy enough to know that.
x/d with
Roa and
Pitch