[Pitchwife]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

He questions Legate about his guard choices, but asks them why he thinks those two stand out from the others. Looking to hone in on possible gifteds Pitch?

Sorry, no. Just trying to get a read on Legate based on his answers.

But you still end up voting for Kitanna. And if she was your prime suspect why would you have to reluctantly decide it?

It was Day 1, for Goddess's sake! Never had to pick somebody to vote, found one person more suspicious than any others, but couldn't be sure you were right?

But wasn't heard guard Hakon, and guarding the quiet the thing that you said was sensible?

Only when I don't have any more viable candidates, or can't decide between them.

Oh, like your own suspicions against Kitanna were not in fact, plagiarism? *points to #107

In a way, yes. Point taken.

Discards Nerwen and Me as simply looking good. Yet has quite a bit to say about Lommy, sally, and Inzil. 1 known innocent, 1 unknown, and 1 known wolf.

So what exactly is your point?

His reasons for not suspecting sally has nothing to do with her vote for Kitanna, but her vote tallies. And he turns suspicions on Nog and Brinn for pointing out sally's vote tallies.

I just didn't find her tallies a sufficient reason to suspect her, and found it odd that Nog & Brinn suspected her because of that.

He makes no statement of feelings about Inzil at all, the only person in his list of fellow Kit voters, he just wishes to hear more.

Hear more so I could form an opinion about him, which I hadn't at the time, hence no statement.

This is what he says when he votes Legate, kind of a wierd statement to make. You can tell us if you were secretly hoping he was gifted, Pitch, go on the truth sets us free.

This is what Nilp referred to as 'Legate as a test case'. If I remember correctly, about half the village thought that way.

#373 and #375 In both he also defense Inzil, and defends Nogrod.

1 known innocent, and 1 wolf. What does that prove?

Instead of restating what I've done, please point out what it is that made those things make me look suspicious? As I recall, Inzil turned out to be a wolf, my only regret is not following up on a vote for him, or sticking to my guns. His cool reaction was a lot different from the last time I suspected Inzil of wolvery (and was correct).

Yep, you were right about Zil. Go on, rub it in.

I persuaded you to vote for Kit? I've taken responsibility for that crapper mistake, while you continue to blame me for persuading you.

I don't blame you; that was only one point in the post you're referring to, what made me suspicious was everything taken together. You made a point about Kit, I found it convincing; acting upon it (i.e. voting her) was my own responsibility.

What would the point be in actually stating Legate was framed? The reason I suspected Nogrod still, is because I thought after that night when there was one kill, Nogrod immediately came out and tried to pass off he was innocent. However, as I told Nogrod I made an error, it was wilwa and Hakon.

I just thought that after that frame, you might have been more wary of basing suspicions on the NG and single kills. As for the last sentence, sorry, I don't get it.

And me agreeing with someone about one of their suspicions is sketchy...because? Weren't you the one who became persuaded to vote for Kitanna, because of me and Nerwen?

See above.

You know what? Right now, I'm beginning to think I may just be too honest for this game. And I'm getting tired of sackcloth & ashes.
I'm assuming you're coming after me because you honestly suspect me to be a wolf. I don't say the suspicion is unearned, and you do it well. But if you're a wolf driving nails into my coffin to make sure another innocent is lynched, well done too.
Sadly, the truth as you see it will see us all dead.

P.S. Before I forget it:
++Guard McCaber
I think if he was faking, we would have a counter-reveal by now.

(x-ed with a host)