Isn't it funny how so many people defended
Gwath on Day1, because he always gets lynched early on, and then so many people wanted him dead just one day later? Even funnier, much of the suspicion stemmed from his Day1 vote. The rest came from his reaction to being poked. As one of the pokers, I have to say that I found his reaction and later behaviour rather innocent. I'm quite puzzled by this and can't help but suspect Gwath's suspecters. Since
Gwath was the runner-up to
Quacklómien, I could very easily see a conspiracy, maybe only a spontaneous one, of the two other ducks against
Gwath. The question is, did
they try to get him lynched openly, or more behind the scenes. Keep your eyes open, fellow innocents.
They are out there, ever looking for
their next victim. Be watchful, for
they watch you, too. Just like
they wathed
Gwatch.
A look at the votes (1-innocent to 5-guilty):
Mith -> Lommy (1)
Her certainty is astounding and it makes you wonder why she is still alive today - without a ranger save. Could be duck-on-duck, but somewhere something is going on behind the scenes that I don't get. I mean, more than we know of.
[2]
Kath -> Lari (1)
Lari had also been suspected by Durelin, Lommy, and Gwath. This could be seen as an attempt to put another widely mistrusted person to compete with a possible Lommy-waggon. Her other suspect is Gwath, who would also have served the same purpose nicely. Her choice of top-suspects is somewhat suspicious. The fact that Lommy didn't go with Lari exonerates her.
[3]
Lommy -> Gwath (1)
[6]
Mac -> Lommy (2)
[0]
Wilwa -> Gwath (2)
She goes along the same lines as Kath (same top suspects), which I think makes it unlikely that they both are ducks. Chooses Gwath over Lari, possibly because his waggon had more momentum (and possibly to follow her fellow's vote?).
[4]
Rikae -> Mith (1)
Could be seen as an attempt to her vote out of the expectable race between Lommy, Gwath, and Lari. Only, evil-Rikae would never have done that.
[2]
Nienna -> Gwath (3)
Also considers Mith, in a way that could be called a slight defense of Lommy. Chooses Gwath, who out of the given options was her top suspect.
[4]
Brinn -> Lommy (4)
Putting the Lommy-waggon back on its rails. I think a duck would have refrained from making this vote.
[1]
Fea -> Lommy (5)
Same as above, since they cross-voted.
[1]
Gwath -> Lommy (6)
The logical choice.
[2]
Durelin -> Lommy (7)
Has been after Lommy and Lari and chooses Lommy for obvious reasons. Unsuspicious.
[1]
Lari -> Gwath (4)
The last two posts before her vote were counts. Before that, she listed Lommy as guilty and Gwath as unsure. Very suspicious.
[5]
Izzy -> Lari (2)
Very consequent. No reason to suspect.
[1]
Nogrod -> Lommy (8)
A model of indecisiveness, completely on the fence between Lommy and Gwath. Waits with his vote til it already had been decided. This is typical for him, but that does not mean that he couldn't be a duck trying to get away with it.
[3]
Nerwen -> Lommy (9)
Pulls a Nog, but messes up the timing. It takes years of experience to do his trick.
The thing in her favour is that an evil Nerwen would probably have acted more determinedly.
[3]
PS:
*ignores the entire
tp's apprentice thing*
*enjoys absence of headache*
PPS:
Nilp is cracked. Cracked rhymes with quacked. He must be evil, logically.