[Macalaure]

All quotes by Aganzir.

I don't understand what this talk about double lynch is. Just because Fea is most likely a baddie, do we have to take a risk of lynching an innocent as well (and I'm not speaking only about a double lynch I'd be a part of)?

Risk? Chance!

Since Fea is a goner, we have the chance to lynch another baddie as well. Might go wrong, sure, but so can every lynch.

We are given an opportunity here and we should seize it!

Still I don't think two people are enough to cause a bandwagon when there are still so many people alive.

Ilya did, too. In fact, the way she voiced her suspicions against me was what got me on her track and made me take a close look at her on which I saw a couple of suspicious things which made me vote her. Also, I consider Boro to be a Mac-vote waiting to happen.

In a way I don't know what to make of Mac's 'Rikae told me...' things. If he's a wolf, it wouldn't be very nice to use reasons like that.

Rikae was more or less looking over my shoulder and told me this and that, so I saw no reason not to mention that. Has nothing to do with my role.

It looks like it was enough for him to came up with someone he could vote before leaving without any actual reasons.

I didn't point it out because I thought it to be obvious: the reason to leave that I had was RL. My suspicion of Menel was not much indeed, but all that I could come up with. Any other vote would have been random.

The "Would anyone please act very, very suspicious within the next half hour?" meant that I was largely clueless and was joking about somebody to please be obviously suspicious before I had to vote half an hour later. I seriously fail to see the scariness of that.

but here Mac denies having any thought process

You can't seriously take my jokes and hold them against me as evidence... sheesh

What exactly made him sound more innocent there?

No particular quote, just the way he retaliated his suspicion and vote. Seemed very innocent.

He didn't suspect me despite me bringing up points against him. Okay my points weren't very big but still.

Had nothing to do with their size, but whether they appeared to be honest and genuine. They seemed so to me, so I had no reason to counter the suspicion.

Mind you, Gwath had two suspects, and I think he had more of a reason to suspect Nog than Lari.

Yes, but, no offense, both suspicions were very weak. The carelessness was, in my opinion, that he didn't try harder to look for suspects. It's kind of hilarious that you accuse me of doing what defend Gwath for doing to a much larger extent.

and I'm rather certain Nog would've been lynched even if it wasn't for Gwath's vote.

That is most certainly wrong.

he didn't analyse those people who retracted to save Nog until later.

I did. I considered it innocentish, but I found that so obvious that I didn't use many words and had to elaborate later.

What kind of connection did you see between Ilya and Brinn, Mac?

Some of the things she found suspicious of others could have been applied to Brinn, too, but weren't. That made me suspicious. If you want me to, I can elaborate.

I think he's overreacting.

I was. I had just finished my analysis and then saw one that came to the opposite conclusion and ignored an important possibility (Fea=cobbler).

He tries to justify it by saying that if Fea is the cobbler, lynching her is just what she wants us to do. But when has Fea actually been declared the cobbler? Yes she could be, but she could also be a critic. Or innocent.

That's not the actual justification, just and additional point. She is almost certainly evil, and if she's the cobbler, we basically end up wasting a lynch, which is right up the cobbler's alley.

So it's practically all the same to him who we lynch as long as it is a double lynch?

Of course not. I want to double lynch the person that we consider most likely to be a critic. I think that is you, but if the other singers think otherwise (unless, of course, I really think that person is innocent) I'd be willing to give it a shot with him. We have a very good chance to lynch two baddies at once. We should take it.

I hope Mac appreciates this because it took me ages to finish.

Very, very much appreciated! It was fun to read and write these replies, though their length is unworthy of the analysis they are replying to.

You look neither more nor less suspicious to me than before. Your analysis has a few very good points and it often goes way past it's mark. Your analysis is clearly not unbiased, but I'm not holding that against you. If I were innocent and in your position, I would not be able to analyse the person who wants to double-lynch me objectively either.

I still want to double-lynch you , but I rather doubt it's going to happen.