The seer did get a dream in night 1, didn't he?
tgwbs definitely didn't dream of the phantom in Night 1. This speaks clearly against it:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tgwbs
Wild Man feel phantom speaks logic. But phantom indeed tricksy. Menel correct, perhaps phantom cobbler. But Wild Man believe not.
|
Yet, tgwbs was clearly after his tricksy folk on Day 1, tp and Fea. He voted Fea in the end.
http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showpos...&postcount=113
There are a couple in here that he could have dreamt of and found innocent. If he dreamt of a baddie, it had to be
Fea. He is not that clear about anybody else.
The whole situation would make a lot of sense if
Fea is the cobbler. If she is a critic,
tgwbs would probably have died last night already. If she is the cobbler, the critics wouldn't have suspected tgwbs very much before, and only got the crucial information before Night 2.
This fits into the mold:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tgwbs
Even if she not wolf, she deserve!
|
It would also explain
tgwbs's sigh before his vote. If he knew that
Fea was the cobbler, he probably expected her to dream of him and then die.
http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showpos...&postcount=284
Options: he dreamt of me and found me to be the ordo that I am; he dreamt of
Gwath and found him guilty (note how the end of the line about
Gwath is the same as the end of the line about
Fea).
http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showpos...&postcount=286
He did not dream of
Brinn.
Kath and
Boro could have been found innocent, but looking at tgwbs's posts from Day 1, I don't think those two are likely dreams.
http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showpos...&postcount=300
Now he put me into the more suspicious lot, so he did not dream of me. If he dreamt of
Boro, then he likely did so in Night 1 instead of
Fea. What he says about
Aganzir, along with him putting her on the same line with
Fea, indicates that she has been dreamt of and has been found guilty. Since he was one of the failed
Nogrod-savers, a dream of the most crucial
Nogrod-voter would make a lot of sense. A dream of
Gwath is less likely given his position in the list. Note that
Boro and
Kath are not on the same line:
Kath has not been dreamt of. While he was suspicious of her on Day 1, he backed off it before the deadline.
In #329, it sounds like
tgwbs does think of
Fea as a critic, not a cobbler. He does not pursue
Aganzir the way he pursues
Fea, which makes a dream of
Aganzir less likely.
http://forum.barrowdowns.com/showpos...&postcount=345
Then again, he keeps on writing their names on the same line...
If it wouldn't be so unlikely that
tgwbs dreamt of
Kath, I would consider it possible that he dreamt of her and
Boro and found them innocent. However, he definitely dreamt of
Fea. Anything else is inconceivable. It is also quite inconceivable that
tgwbs wrote one known-to-him baddie on the same line with an only suspected baddie. Therefore:
Night 1:
Fea
Night 2:
Aganzir
*requests double lynch*
I'm not surprised at all that
Fea and
Aganzir are so eager to be the first to analyse tgwbs...
I have not yet read all the other analyses. I'll do that right away.