Possibilities...
1) Walter viewed
TGWBS on Night 2. The info was received by the Critics last Night and they acted upon it.
2) The Critics came to believe on their own that
TGWBS was the Seer.
Implications of option 1-
Fea would then be the likely Walter candidate, dreamed of on Night 1. But then who was the Night 2 dream? Critic
Agan? An innocent
Boro or
Kath? But both
Fea-
Agan and
Boro-
Kath were listed in pairs as "most guilty" and "most innocent". Would
TGWBS pair a certain with an uncertain? Unless his
Fea vote was meant to separate her from
Agan despite the pairing. Which opens up the possibility that I was his Night 2 dream.
Implications of option 2-
This would be possible if both
Boro and
Kath are innocent, but even more likely if
Fea and
Agan are both guilty. One on each list perhaps? Only if
Fea is guilty, I would say. If he pegged only a guilty
Agan, I can't imagine
Agan being that touchy about it. Unless she feared that
Fea was Walter, of course.
Option 3, which I hope is not what happened-
TGWBS, in order to remain hidden through the first couple days, gave no clear clues, or even incorrect clues, about his dreams. But through bad fortune Walter dreamed him and he was done in before he could tell us what we really thought.
Option 1 strikes me as the most likely, largely due to
TGWBS's statement on Day 1-
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by TGWBS
++FEANOR
Even if she not wolf, she deserve!
|
Now, this would seem to say "Fea=Walter".
And if she is indeed Walter, I can see why she might spy him the following Night. And then that info gets passed on and he is slain the Night after.
Unless of course he worded it that way because she is a Critic (to avoid detection). This would mesh better with the attempt on my life Night 2. For if she is indeed Walter, wouldn't she have spied me Night 1? And then the Critics receive her report, which I presume would read "Walter found Phantom to be- The Opera Ghost". And if that's what they received, why would they kill me? Surely they wouldn't think "The Opera Ghost" meant "Seer", and certainly not "Divo". They definitely wouldn't try and kill a supsected invincible Divo.
Unless- they believed I was one of the Lovers, as I was indeed pretending to be. And they saw that I had asked for my "Christine" to step up, and so they believed that "Opera Ghost" was simply the designation for one of the Lovers.
Thoughts?
EDIT: x-post Agan/Fea