Oops!
Quote:
Originally Posted by McCaber
And I would not view my Day 2&3 votes as safe and early. They both came about half an hour before DL, and I tried to start bandwaggons against she who I knew was a wolf.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
And Mac would say my evidence is weak. Granted that's not the entire schibang against Nerwen (I wouldn't even call it the potatoes), but it looks that's a bit of a stretch.
|
I don't think I have any evidence as such as evidence is a rare treat in a WW-game. But I'd say the cumulative effect of small things that could be seen as pointing at the same direction does make me actually suspect
Nerwen.
Talking about streching, I must agree with
Nerwen that
McCaber hasn't been quite caught yet - even if I agree he looks suspicious as well and his posting toDay hasn't helped his position in my eyes.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro over voting on Day3
When Nerwen votes for me, she crosses with McCaber's vote for sally, and Mith's vote for Lal.
So the situation was...
Nogrod - 2
Mith - 2
sally - 1
Lal - 1
Nerwen adds me to the list, while sally and Lal both receive their 2nd votes. I'm not quite sure what to make of this. Sally was a wolf, and if Nerwen's a wolf, why would she spread the vote more? Why wouldn't she try to create some distance for sally? I mean she did have Lal (the believed cobbler) to sacrifice if needed, to try and create a diversion/get sally out of focus. Spreading the vote in that situation doesn't make sense for a wolf.
|
This situation I think is worth a second (and a third, and fourth...) look even if we couldn't get anything conclusive - either way - out of it.
Nerwen had somewhat openly suspected
Lalwendë of cobblery but said she wished to go for a wolf rather than cobbler. I can see the point behind that - but also a wolf (if she thought
Lal was indeed the cobbler which wouldn't be too far-fetched) would have loved to let the cobbler live.
Why then not vote for me or
Mith to save
Sally? She had made a few ligt suspicions on us both the earlier Day because of us suspecting
Gwath for reasons she didn't think were good - or
Mith being a possible WoW -voter.
Now one thing comes to mind - if she is a wolf that is - as the main reason for
Sally to get into the mess she was in in the first place was her "saving vote" for
CoD on Day1. Now
Nerwen would surely like to avoid that kind of attention and not the least if she were going to be the last wolf standing, and voting for me or
Mith might have raised some eyebrows if and when
Sally got lynched one Day and were revealed the wolf she was.
In that case voting
Boro was a safe bet for her - looks consistent and not like saving
Sally.
I have in mind an innocent
Nerwen scenario as well but I think she should produce it herself...
Interstingly
Nerwen has basically nothing to say of
Sally even if she was on everyone's mouth and ascted pretty suspicipusly indeed. Only on Day2 she notifies her strange manouvres with
CoD but even that post ends up in a way whitewashing
Sally. After that there is no mention of
Sally in her posts (at least I didn't find one).
*Confused*
