A look at
Isabellkya
Day1
#47 makes some semi-serious comments on
Rikae and
Fea.
#82 thinks it's possible
Shasta voted
Boro out of revenge. Says it would be nice to catch a wolf on Day1, "but I don't think it
HAS TO HAPPEN". Sympathizes with
Brinn but doesn't think I had evil intentions when going after her.
"It doesn't have to happen" combined with "It happened!" is a little strange.
#103 ponders
Shasta a little and then says
Quote:
I am off now..so, I suppose this is a throw away vote at best..
++CoD
|
Throw away? If she said it was a random vote, I would believe her, but the second vote for
CoD at this point was by no means a throwaway. Why did she say this?
Day2
#160 explains her vote with
Quote:
Wow.
What a strike of luck.
My voting on CoD was pretty darn random. I was trying to make a vote while trying to get out the door at the same time. His voting of Day One stood out in my mind the most, so I figured heh why not.
|
Not exactly consistent with what she said before. Nothing new either.
#194 will look at
Nogrod and
Boro because of buddybuddy-ness and a "few things
Nogrod said". She says she wants to look at
Sally for the point
Boro brought up earlier.
#204 detailed analysis of
Nogrod and
Sally. Concludes she will keep an eye on
Nogrod. No clear conclusion on
Sally.
This one looks actually pretty genuine.
#225 good observation about
Lalwende
#233 votes
Nogrod
Day3
#281 wonders why
Brinn was killed because she expected another trail-less kill. Gives a vote tally without comments.
#283 questions
Lal
#316 accuses
Boro of copying his arguments
#320 defends her accusation and herself
#349 explains herself to
Boro about her points about the relation between
Boro and
Nogrod
#359 contemplates
Lal's cobblerdom (part of that is pondering her giftedness, which raises my eyebrow) says she will vote
Nogrod or
Sally
#377 votes
Nogrod
A bit defensive this day.
Day4
#449 makes good points against
Nogrod
#476 after
Nilp revealed, she thinks
McCaber and
I are innocent,
Boro,
Lal, and
Fea could be cobblers,
Nerwen and
Mith she's undecided about. No wolf suspects there! Other than that, the list almost scarily coincides with my own suspicions.
#489 had a closer look at
Mith and didn't find anything too alarming
#498 votes
Fea because everyone else looks innocent, cobblerish, or should be left to
Nilp
Now, at first glance this looks all rather innocent, and it probably is, but I could also see this scenario:
Izzy is very consistent about
Nogrod and
Sally. Now
Sally was dead and
Nogrod innocent. As a wolf, you usually have to make fake cases against some innocents, but you'd like to minimize their number in order to minimize retaliation. Did
Izzywolf choose
Nogrod to be her perpetual scapegoat? And then, after he's innocent, she's a bit lost and can't get herself to make a new fake case against an innocent, simply because what everyone else does is just so darn innocent (in the wolf's eye (I at least always feel that way as a wolf))?
ToDay
#532 defends her vote to
Boro
#544 says she will look at
Mith,
Nerwen, and
Fea. This statement about
Boro is quite fishy:
Quote:
|
Since Lal died as the Cobbler, I suppose that puts Boro in a bit of better light. Leaving him either innocent or wolf. Though, Sally's vote for him on Day 1 is kind of bugging me.
|
Well, well, a clear-cut wolf suspect surely looks different. There are a few things that look fishy, and under the magnifying glass (and given the surrounding statements), her Day1 vote doesn't look perfectly innocent anymore.
She suspects
Sally but doesn't vote for her. This could indicate that
CoD's death was not intended and she'd like to keep
Sally around, but at the same time can't overlook the suspicious things
Sally did.
PS: this is definitely the last long analysis I will do in this game. Even for a more quiet player it's starting to become seriously toilsome.
