Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
That logic doesn't hold; if I said only a stupid dog would fall down the steps, and my dog is not stupid, therefor he would never fall down the steps. That statement would false, because my dog has fallen down the steps.
|
A dog has fallen down the stairs. Your dog is smart, therefore the chances that it was him are slim. (I never said it would
never fall.)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
Just look at the evidence for what it is, no attached feelings or opinions, just look at it.
|
I look at it and I see a clear record. As long as I see better options, I think it's madness to go for somebody with a clear record! Yes, I admit his vote for you doesn't look good, but if I was innocent, had a clear record, and then saw your case and vote, I would have been upset, too. Concerning him trying to convince us he's a nearly known innocent, I give you that one. But these are not enough to change my mind. Not yet.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
Because it's more just an unconscious reaction than anything else, you can't just have this "turn off" switch that you have special information because you're a wolf.
|
Umm, yes, you can. At least you know you have to. Many, maybe most, wolves aren't able to do it consistently, but to consistently
not do it, that's just not what an even moderately smart wolf - usually - would do.
As I said, I'm not writing him off, but right now I don't think that lynching him is a good idea.