Now that the other Saruman thread has died down a bit...
Quote:
|
The passage in question doesn't concern who would master the ring _in general_, but who could master the ring in Sauron's presence. Maybe only Gandalf can master the ring in such a situation, but that doesn't exclude the fact that others can master the ring properly, should Sauron not be in the vicinity.
|
Please explain how a physical confrontation with Sauron could possibly be avoided by this putative ringlord. How could said ringlord be sure they had mastered the Ring when they fought Sauron? I picture the Ring having a thought process similar to this...
Ring: Hmmm...another dullard who thinks they can master me. What to do? I know! I'll pretend like they've mastered me and get their ego all blown out of proportion. My new "master" will fall all over itself (har, har "it"self, clever reference to part of the discussion in other thread
) to take me back to my Master.
*time passes, battle is waged, Sauron makes beeline for new "ringlord"*
Ring: DADDY!!!!!!!
*BAM* new ringlord is jello
Ring and Sauron: Boo-YAA!!!