Okay.
Here are my thoughts so far. I will continue this, but these were the "easiest" to form an opinion to begin with...
Naria: Not posted yet, nothing to say.
Briseis: Not posted yet, nothing to say.
Eonwe: Not posted yet, nothing to say. But him being the quiet wolf in my last game makes me quite reserved with anything he will say or do in this game. I know it is unfair, but I will look at him very closely this time around, as and if he comes around...
Glirdan: Has basically just reported in... Nothing to say so far.
Gil: Two posts. Not much to take hold on. Defending
Rikae somewhat but playing it down also:
Quote:
|
Aye, Rikae is not that suspicous in my eye, but if she turns out to actually be a thing then we've all been played for fools this first day.
|
Voting
Rune with no apparent reason given, but:
Quote:
|
Thus my vote must go to Rune, it probably won't be to effect but its a start.
|
I might say this is "Gil-Galadish", even quite outspoken version from his family-tree... Hard to say. And with my last experience with
Eonwe, I would not exclude him from my vote toDay. But surely, no good reasons to suspect him either but only to be certain about him...
Meneltarmacil: Two posts so far. I would have awaited more from him (not exactly on numbers but of substance). But he had a point also when saying:
Quote:
|
Catching these Things and making 'em walk the plank will be tough, as you really can't trust anyone, even known innocents. Shiver me timbers, it be a dire scenario! I personally would only follow up on suspicions rather than rely on "known innocents" here, as they have a way of changing on you.
|
That might be said by an innocent or a thing alike. Over this one he only managed to go to and fro with
Rune... Don't know but don't like either. I want to hear more from him.
Folwren: two posts as well. Ringing innocent to my ears. She is staunchly defending
Rikae for her first post as she was the victim of a similar kind of suspicion in the last one. Sounds true to me. At least what can be said with some confidence is that on the basis of #42 they probably will not be things both of them. That would be too daring at least thinking of
Folwren (Sorry Foley
). Generally she seems to be very sensible indeed and speaking the words of wisdom. Not my suspect for the time being (tomorrow may be different as this game will be crazy enough with the switching identities).
So seven people on this "easy" list. With the probabilities at least one of them is a thing... So who? Hard to say as some of them have not yet posted, but
Menel should come forwards if he wishes to avoid my suspicions.
Gil I'm a bit embarrased about (wouldn't like to be leading yet another lynch of an innocent
Gil) as he justmade a post suspicious enough... And
Eonwe I can't vote before he says anything and will (unfairly) look at him really closely this time...
Very hard to say.
Hopefully my look on the more difficult cases proves a better guide...