[Arwen_Evenstar]

I agree to an extent...<BR>Firstly ,you see, PJ made a very bold move, trying to create this movie. Many people thought it couldn't be done because of it's plot, physical description of characters and creatures and whatnot, so he should be commended for that first and foremost.<BR>Secondly, I think, in general, that he did a pretty good job on the movies! I agree with Esgallhugwen aswell; unfourtunatley, not everyone has read these wonderful books, so he'd have to make a movie that everyone could watch, not just book fans, or he'd lose a large percent of the income, which would probobly leave him very much in debt. <BR>However, I believe he could have done more to satisfy us,<I>and</I>let others know what was going on, while ALSO staying true to the book. For example, Faramir. I see no reason for turning him all evil and angry, when he could of remained loyal to Gondor. To me, he represented the little strength that was left in the world of men, so when PJ screwed around with him, I sort of went haywire. <BR>So I agree, but don't agree....<BR>Hmmm...<BR>~nat~