yeah! i know im off, but can you give me a hint of where i went wrong. i mean, a more specific hint?

Ok...

You don't need to involve Elwing at all.

Ingil -s> Ingwë -b> Indis -m> Finarfin -f> Galadriel -m> Celebrian -m> Arwen -d> Elrond -s> Earendil-f> Elros -f> Vardamir -f> Amandil -f> Elendil -f> Silmarien -m> Valandil -f> ..... -f> Eärendur
-gf> Númendil -f> Elendil -f> Anarion -f> Melendil -f> Cemendur -f> Earendil ( of Gondor.)
-f> Anardil -f> Ostoher -f> Tarostar -f> Turambar -f> Atanatar I -f> Siriondil -f> Tarkiryan -f> Eärnil I -f> Ciryandil -f> Hyarmendacil I -f> Atanatar II -f> Calmacil -f> Minalcar -f> Valakar -f> Eldacar -s> Galadwen -d> Vidugavia -f> ..... -f> Marhari -f> Marhwini -f> Forthwini -gf> Frumgar -f> Fram -f> Léod -f> Eorl -f> Brego -f> Aldor -f> Frea -f> Freawine -f> Goldwine -f>Deor -f> Gram -f> Hild -m> Frealaf -f> Brytta -f> Walda -f> Folca -f> Folcwine -f> Fengel -f> Thengel -f> Theodwyn -m> Éowyn -m> Elboron

Oooh... you're very close


But, I'm afraid, I'm going to be nitpicky, and you have one or two tiny errors in there.

Can you give me a hint? Because i'm just too lazy

Sorry, Perky Ent, I'm giving this one to Silmarien for both effort and almost-there accuracy. Of course, there were a couple of things that were wrong (i.e. Elendil's good ol' da is Amandil), but I'm giving it to you for effort.

BTW, Perky Ent, take a look at this (it's part of your post):


How in bright heaven did you get from Dior of the First Age to Barahir and then to Rian and then to Denethor I??????

<font size=1 color=339966>[ 10:31 PM February 05, 2004: Message edited by: Finwe ]

Silmarien, if you're there, please make up a new thingie for this game!

Sorry about my mistake but it took a while to type it all out and then when it was wrongish I couldn't be stuffed checking then typing it all again. Anyway try this.

Theoden and Denethor two ways.

This should be easy!

Theoden -s> Thengel -f> Theodwyn -m> Eowyn -m> Elboron -s> Faramir s-> Denethor


Well, glad that's over!

<font size=1 color=339966>[ 1:24 AM February 08, 2004: Message edited by: The Perky Ent ]

Aye but tis only one way, I asked for two.

Theoden -s> Thengel -f> Theodwyn -m> Eomer -f> Elfwine -s> Lothiriel -d> Imrahil -s> Adrahil -f> Finduilas -m> Boromir -s> Denethor

Theoden -s> Thengel -f> Theodwyn -m> Eowyn -m> Elboron -s> Faramir -s> Denethor

The Night Knight has pray continue good sir.

Not in the Rules
 

<font color=red>Silmarien, although it is true that NightKnight has answered your question, you don't get to ask for two different answers at a time. It's one per question! </font color=red>

Orodreth -> Turin

Which Orodreth?
 

Orodreth -s> Aldarion -s> Earendur -f> Amlaith -f> Beleg -f> Mallor -f> Celepharn -f> Celebrindor -s> Malvegil -s> Argeleb I -s> Arveleg I -s> Araphor -f> Argeleb II -f> Arvegil -f> Arveleg II -f> Araval -f> Araphant -f> Arvedui -f> Aranarth -f> Arahael -f> Aranuir -f>Aravir -f> Aragorn I -f> Araglas -f> Arahad I -s> Aragost -f> Aravorn -f> Arahad II -f> Arassuil -f> Arathorn I -f> Argonui -f> Arador -f> Arathorn II -f> Aragorn II -f> Eldarion -s> Arwen -d> Elrond -s> Elwing -d> Dior -s> Beren -s> Barahir -s> Bregor -s> Bregolas -f> Baragund -f> Morwen -m> Turin

nk?
 

NightKnight? Please post!

Actually, you have the wrong Orodreth. The one I meant is the elf in Silm. Nice work though.

OK Then how about this!
 

Orodreth -s> Finarfin -f> Galadriel -m> Celebrian -m> Arwen -d> Elrond -s> Elwing -d> Dior-s> Beren -s> Barahir -s> Bregor -s> Bregolas -f> Baragund -f> Morwen -m> Turin

Now does it work?

Just one tiny mistake: Bregor -s> Bregolas. Bregor was the father of Bregolas, not the other way around, but you'll get it anyway. :)

Let's see...i need to think of a really hard one! OH! This will do:

Pelendur ---> Indis


That should occupy y'all for a while!

:smokin: :smokin:

Pelendur -?> House of Hurin -s> Hurin of Emyn Arnen -?> (Numenorean descent) -s> Elros Tar-Minyatur -s> Earendil -s> Idril -d> Turgon -s> Fingolfin -s> Indis

I hate to nit pic, but i like to watch you suffer, Finwe! You can fill in the blanks! Here's a hint! If my memory serves right, Pelendur is either the 1st or 2nd steward. You can trace the line of stewards until you can find other links that weave in and out of the fabric of the Stewards of Gondor!

Anyone want to take a stab at it?

...anybody...

I've found a solution, but it contains one or two small holes. Is it possible to do it without them?

*Pant* I haven't done this before*Pant*But I think*Pant*I have it.

Peledur -f> Mardil-f> Eradan -f>Herion -f> Belegorn -f> Hurin I -f> Turin I -f> Hador -f> Barahir -f> Dior - succeded by> Denethot I -f> Boromir I -f> Cirion -f> Hallas -f> Hurin II -f> Belecthor I -f> Orodreth -f> Ecthalion - succeded by> Egalmath -f> Beren -f> Beregond -Belcthor II -f> Thorondir-f> Turin II- f> Turgon-f> Ecthalion II -f> Denethor II -f> Faramir -f> Elboron -s> Eowyn-d> Theodwyn-d>Thengel-s> Fengel-s> Flocwine -s> Floca-s> Walda -s> Leofa -s>Frelaf -s> Hilde-d>Gram -s> Deor -s> Goldwine s-> Freawine -s>Frea-s> Aldor -s>Brego -s>Eorl- s>Leod-s>Fram-s>Frumgar-grandson of>Forthwini-s>Marhwini-s>Marhari -Northman descendants> Vidugavia -f> Vidumavi -m> Vinitharya-s>Aldamir-s> Eldacar-s>valacar-s>Minalcar-s>Calmacil-s>Narmacil-s>Atanatar II-s>Hyarmendacil I-s>Ciryandil-s>Earnil I- succeded by>Tarannon-s>Sirindil-s>atanatar I-s>Turambar-s>Tarostar-s>Ostoher-s>Hardil-s>Earendil-s>Cemendar-s>Meneldil-s>Anarion-s>Elendil-f>Isildur-f>Valandil-f>Eldacar-f>Elendur-f>Earendur-f>Amlaith-f>Beleg-f>Mallor-f>Celepharn-f>Celebrindol-f>Malvegil-f>Argeleb I-f>Arveleg I-f>Araphor-f>Argeleb II-f>Arvegil-f>Arveleb II-f>Arvegil-f>Arveleg II-f> Araval -f> Araphant -f> Arvedui -f> Aranarth -f> Arahail -f> Aranuir -f> Aravir -f> Aragorn I -f> Araglas -f> Arahad I -f> Aragost -f> Aravorn -f> Arahad II -f> Arassuil -f> Arathorn I -f> Argonui -f> Arador -f> Arathorn II -f> Aragorn II -f> Eldarion -s> Arwen -d> Celebrian -d> Galadriel -d> Finarfin -s> Indis

Looks good Arvedui! *wink* your go! *wink*

Umm...yeah. Thanks *Looks quizicly at the Perky Ent and winks back.*

Ok then, maybe something easy(ier) for a change.

Cirion--->Eorl

Edit: Opps, sorry. Cirdan and Cirion are different people.

Cirion -f> Hallas -f> Hurin II -f> Belecthor I -f> Morwen -grandm> Egalmoth -f> Beren -f> Beregond -f> Belecthor II -f> Thorondir -f> Turin II -f> Turgon -f> Ecthelion II -f> Denethor II -f> Faramir -f> Elboron -s> Eowyn -d> Theodwyn -d>Thengel -s> Fengel -s> Flocwine -s> Floca-s> Walda -s> Leofa -s>Frelaf -s> Hilde-d>Gram -s> Deor -s> Goldwine s-> Freawine -s>Frea-s> Aldor -s> Brego -s>Eorl

Herm...yup, that's it. Your go Perky Ent.

OK. How about:


Nerdanel ---> Brandir

Nerdanel -m> Maedhros -s> Feanor -s> Finwe -f> Fingolfin -f> Turgon -f> Idril -m> Earendil -s> Tuor -s> Huor -s> Galdor -s> Hador -f> Gloredhel -m> Handir -f> Brandir

That's a big 10-4 NK! Your go!

Thank you. :)

Reginard Took -> Lotho Sackville-Baggins

Well, let's see:

Reginard Took -s> Adelard Took -s> Flambard Took -s> Isembard Took -s> Geronitus Took -f> Belladonna -m> Bilbo Baggins -s> Bungo Baggins -s> Mungo Baggins -f> Longo Baggins -f> Otho Sackville Baggins -f> Lotho Sackville Baggins

Is that it?

That is indeed it. Good work! :)

We've been doing really hard ones lately, so i'm giving y'all a break!


Frodo Baggins ---> Meriadoc Brandybuck

Frodo Baggins -s> Primula Brandybuck -d> Gorbadoc Brandybuck -f> Rorimac Brandybuck -f> Saradoc Brandybuck-f> Meriadoc Brandybuck

Yep! Merriadoc is Frodo's...2nd cousin? I'm too lazy. Let's just say he's his...Relation! Your turn, NightKnight!

Aren't all hobbits related in one way or another? :D

Anyway, try Adrahil -> Hurin of the Keys